EXT1 — External browser-tier review round · chat-link manifest
Round: EXT1 (first fully automated web-app-tier external round) Submitted: 2026-06-10, ~15:30–16:05 PDT, via /external-review-browser-loop (gstack browse, logged-in GStack Chromium profile) Papers: all six, current live versions (md5-verified against site mirrors pre-submission) Providers/models: ChatGPT GPT-5.5 Pro Extended (slowest, deepest) · Grok Heavy (Team of Experts) · Gemini 3.5 Thinking Reuse policy: for the EXT2 follow-up after revisions, return to these SAME chat URLs and post the revised PDF + delta-prompt in-thread to keep referee context.
Chat links
| Paper | Version | PDF (md5) | ChatGPT · Pro Extended | Grok · Heavy | Gemini · 3.5 Thinking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1A | v1A.0.56 | paper1a_ech_nogo_v1A.0.56.pdf (96f18a36) | chat | chat | chat |
| P1B | v1B.0.54 | paper1b_mcmc_companion_v1B.0.54.pdf (bd19ee37) | chat | chat | chat |
| P2 | v1.7.48 | paper2_fnl_forecast_v1.7.48.pdf (4cb0963e) | chat | chat | chat |
| P3 | v3.1.87 | paper3_anomaly_catalog_v3.1.87.pdf (acde55ca) | chat | chat | chat |
| P4 | v1.0.171 | chirality_catalog_paper_v171.pdf (2f0317c4) | chat | chat | chat |
| P5 | v0.1.60 | p5_desi_chirality_v0.1.60.pdf (20ffc154) | chat | chat | chat |
All 18 submissions carried the paper page's calibration-armed referee prompt (scraped live from bigbounce.hubify.app per-paper pages) with model/effort verified in the UI before each send (pre-submit screenshots were captured in the session log for each send).
Harvest status
| Paper | ChatGPT Pro Extended | Grok Heavy | Gemini 3.5 Thinking |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1A | HARVESTED — REJECT | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MAJOR |
| P1B | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MINOR | HARVESTED — MINOR |
| P2 | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MINOR | HARVESTED — MINOR |
| P3 | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MAJOR |
| P4 | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MINOR | HARVESTED — MINOR |
| P5 | HARVESTED — MAJOR | HARVESTED — MINOR | HARVESTED — MAJOR |
All 18 reports harvested 2026-06-10 16:40–17:25 PDT → EXT1_<paper>_<Provider>.md (this directory). Next: /peer-review-truth-audit.
Operational note (encoded in skill): Gemini discards a conversation if you navigate away before its first response completes — the original P1A–P4 Gemini chats were lost and resubmitted sequentially (URLs above are the persisted resubmissions). ChatGPT/Grok persist immediately.