Activity

A2 lapse-monopole gap reconciled per independent adjudication (research/theory_audit/a2_lapse_monopole_adjudication_2026_09_07.md). Sec. II and Appendix A: the earlier 'not reconciled / open item' wording on the uniform-density f^rho gap is

A2 lapse-monopole gap reconciled per independent adjudication (research/theory_audit/a2_lapse_monopole_adjudication_2026_09_07.md). S9's constraint solve A2=eps(3-eps)^2/3 stands as correct (not 2(3-eps)^2). The uniform-density-surface sque

S9c derivation-statement update in Sec II and Appendix A: dropped-evolution-term hypothesis NOT supported; both -55/16 (uniform-density) and -5 (comoving) delta N values are well-defined; 15/16 gap relocated to second-order threading maps l

S9c: dropped-evolution-term hypothesis NOT supported; independent exact separate-universe solution reproduces both -55/16 (uniform-density) and -5 (comoving) for all epsilon; 15/16 gap relocated to second-order threading maps lapse monopole

S9b derivation-statement correction: intrinsic flat-slice term vanishes in the growing-mode limit, does not close the -55/16 gap; residual is an open item in the super-Hubble evolution step. Flagship -35/16 unaffected. Readiness held 75, ro

S9b: intrinsic term does not close the -55/16 gap (vanishes in growing-mode limit); residual is an open item in the super-Hubble evolution step. Readiness held 65, rounds stopped R2.

v2B.0.23: closed three remaining deferred text items from the v2B.0.20 R3 truth audit. D-R3-06: added the commit-ordered batch-3 audit trail (dcf96696 rules-frozen -> d03fe376 pre-registration -> b19b72fc attempt-1 seal -> 60917635 attempt-

v2B.0.22: closed deferred D-R3-21 (recompute of two remaining injected-angle sigmas). Recomputed all three injected-angle recovery statistics (0.270deg, 0.342deg, 0.000deg-null) directly from the committed physical_spectrum_v2/bandpowers.np

R3 closure plan (i): batch-4 R8 post-commitment verifier challenge integrated; R7 restated as prover-predictable; batch-3 stats corrected to class-level counts (30/30); four-batch protocol; Freivalds/Fiat-Shamir prior art; venue statement a

Added DESI DR1 BGS_BRIGHT-21.5 external environment result (row-16 iv-b): spec-z 3D N=121,417 and projected N=949,584 parity-fraction-by-density-contrast table + null verdict (largest excursion projected node-like f_CW z=+2.96, p=0.084 corr

Integrated Batch 3 pre-registered blind-shortcut-detection round (R7 value-level rule; 48 runs, 8 arms x 6; S6 effective-multipole caught 6/6; S5 forgery still escapes 6/6; S4b cross-run disjunct 4/6) and a PyMaster (NaMaster 3.0.1) cross-c

S7 literature correction: Cai factor-of-2 uniform across Eqs.(38)-(41)+Fig.5, not narrowly (38)-(40); rounds stay stopped under R2.

S7 literature correction: Cai (2009) Eq.(37) is the correct shape function; Eqs.(38)-(41)/Fig.5 uniformly 2x Eq.(37); softened Li-reuses-Cai wording.

Row-16 disclosure integrated: pixel-level injection calibration (N=20k) calibrating the label-level A95 curve; full-parent (3.2M-galaxy) selection behavior disclosed as a confidence-cut/DES-leg systematic (not subtracted); 15-statistic pre-

D-A3-14 (ledger row 19): the (r,fnl) no-go generalizes to the full P(X) k-essence class. r=24c_s and the bounce cubic term are exactly lambda-independent; no lambda/Sigma opens the window; DBI best case r_min=12.57 (349x BK18). lambda=s=0 q

R8 closure (INT_v3 A3M_v3M.0.17_R8_TRUTH_AUDIT_2026-09-04.md, plan i): R8-01 disclose lambda=s=0 k-essence scope (ledger row 19 open item); R8-02 Appendix A prints both initial-label (isotropic -5) and final-label (-25/4+15/4mu^2) maps corr

R2 truth-audit closures E-1..E-11: Eq.(4) sign fix, abstract precision, Cai-2009 ratio correction (4/3 not 8/7), reference fixes + Li-Quintin-Wang-Cai 2017, DPS separate-universes engagement, Table I relabeling, self-contained Appendix A (r

R2 closure: statistics presentation corrected (class-level detection, no run-level intervals, 90% interval labelled correctly), estimator description fixed, traceability + reproducibility recipe; rounds stopped under R2

D-A3-12 (ledger row 18): SVII tensor amplitude — lambda_T = lambda_zeta^S1 identically (row18a_s2_tensor, 1.4e-14 verified), so r_after^S1=24.0 is an identity and r_after^S2=9.4e2 (39x bounce amplification); both exclusions (670x, 2.6e4x) a

R7 truth-audit closure (16 genuinely-new-real items, 0 physics errors beyond scoping/staleness). R7-01: r=16eps=24 scoping split by transmission scheme -- S1 (tensor/scalar share z=a) gives r_after=24 exactly as before; S2's raw-ADM continu

R1 truth-audit closure: batch-2 primary result, pilot disclosure, related work, OTS anchor pending, SEM, appendix

v1S.0.2: closes truth-audit PSU_v1S.0.1_R1 closure plan (E1-E10) + resolved gates S1/S2/S3 under decision D-PSU-1 — retitled/reframed as an exact invertible change-of-variable criterion (not a failure); label-resolved Eq (3) for both worldl

v1S.0.1: first draft of the separate-universe failure-criterion note (ledger row 17; novelty lift 2); R1 board in progress.

D-A3-10/D-A3-11 science reframe (ledger rows 10/14, not a review round): title/abstract reframed to the joint (r,f_NL) no-go. New Sec VII 'The tensor amplitude of the modelled background' -- r=16eps=24 exactly (bounce-invariant, ~670x above

Novelty lift #3 (project-context/NOVELTY_AUDIT_2026-09-04.md #3): reframes namaster-proof around the content-bound execution-receipt primitive it already implements and adds a pre-declared, sealed blind shortcut-detection test (18 runs; S1-

R6 closure (16 genuinely-new real, 0 physics errors): T_B mapping recomputed from committed JSON (10^8-10^10 GeV/eleven decades -> 6e9-6e10 GeV/thirteen decades); Channel I NANOGrav amplitude paired to the free-gamma posterior (shortfall 10

Abstract tightened to <=307 words (PRD-regular cap); all claims preserved at evidential strength

R5 closure C1-C7: S1/S2 transfer-bound scoping (A4, S2 T_fNL~1.03), exact-mode LQC deficit scoped to at-and-below k_LQC (squeezed), NANOGrav Omega_GW h^2 6.3e-10->3.6235e-9, editorial MINORs (body sigma qualifiers, novelty claim narrowed, f

D-A3-9: S2 scheme resolved (raw-ADM finite, not divergent) -- transmitted amplitude reported as two-scheme band S1/S2 (-1.25 to -0.50 at -35/16, Quintin background); ABS-operator statement corrected (contained in S1, exact-mode null 2.1-4.4

R4 editorial closure (15 real items) + science decision D-A3-3: PTA channel restated as a null from the nHz SIGW computation (gamma_pred 5.07, Omega_GW 14.3 dex below NANOGrav); SIGW null-panel figure; Next-steps updated. Rounds stopped und

R3 closure C1-C10: C1(a) PROPAGATE - Table IV f_NL^after rows added (kηB<=1e-2 is an upper bound on k, satisfied most easily at the LSS/CMB pivot); Appendix A added (delta N_c-zeta_Mald derivation transcribed, no new science); induced-GW IR

v3M.0.8: three closed science-gate results integrated -- (1) method-independent squeezed-limit confirmation (classical O(k^0) super-Hubble / Bianchi-I shift decomposition [L]/[K]/[X]/[S] reproduces the in-in -35/16 exactly; delta N_c=(1-eps

Real-KDE injection validation closed: NANOGrav 15-yr KDE grids fetched from public Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.8060824, mirrored to HuggingFace. Injection-recovery re-run on real per-bin KDE curves: gamma=13/3 mean pull +0.016 sigma, gamma=3 cont

Final-review REVISE: abstract cut 450->307 words (all quantitative claims+qualifiers preserved); 30-bin KDE-grid injection restore attempted and failed (Zenodo 8060824 grids not in local/HF/B2 -- honest record in SSOT), Sec IV.C stays on di

R2 CLOSED (round ROUND_2026-09-02-A3M-v3M.0.4-EXACTPDF-d86f484f-R2VERIFY): real 30-bin gamma=13/3 (and gamma=3 control) injection-recovery validation replaces a misdescribed prior injection claim (mean pull -0.026sigma / +0.068sigma over 5

R1 closure: PTA channel states NANOGrav's official 14-bin posterior as primary comparison (30-bin refit secondary, validated by injection); gamma=5 tail Bayes factor/6.37sigma dropped (0 of 320,000 samples support it); transmission bound re

PBH compaction-function channel integrated (item A3-1); first-pass Press-Schechter ordering reversed; ratio-level result A(-35/16)/A(-35/8)=1.732, f_PBH not quotable pending in-lab spectrum

abstract trimmed to 300-word cap; no science change

abstract trimmed to ApJS 250-word cap; no science change

A3 multi-channel paper registered as draft v3M.0.2: skeleton + P2 v2L.0.2 exact-amplitude theory folded in per PAPER_LINEAGE_2026-08-05.md; PBH compaction-function row and one INT board still pending.

R3 final closure: fixed sign-chain regression, restored Eq.(11) orders-of-magnitude honest window (68-74) with P1C relation cited separately, removed directive-Q1 leaks, downgraded B2/B5/B6/B10 to argued-in-paper, fixed Planck-mass label, q

R3 final closure: monopole A_p convention disclosed, object_id fixed, Table 1 schema row merged, CL script docstring corrected, abstract detection-power floor + A_95^CL wording, DR1 companion defined, catalog vs manuscript version clarified

R1 closure: novelty restated as independent confirmation consistent with Li et al. 2016 Eq. 4.19 (not a new discovery); f_NL^rho corrected to 5(eps-7)/8=-55/16; Table II states amplitude per row with r=0.84 defined/sourced/caveated + DESI s

R2 closure: monopole disclosure (f_CW=0.5126562 on primary channel, 75.2%-CCW quarantine cause), genuine 95% CL upper limit via Neyman inversion (A_95^CL~=0.75%), withheld bootstrap z restored, schema+completeness tables, 15 editorial fixes

R2 closure: monopole disclosure (f_CW=0.5126562 on primary channel, 75.2%-CCW quarantine cause), genuine 95% CL upper limit via Neyman inversion (A_95^CL~=0.75%), withheld bootstrap z restored, schema+completeness tables, 15 editorial fixes

R2 closure: 8pi coefficient in O4 corrected (inherited from P1C), operator-list restated (5 distinct densities, rank 4), O5 parity-even off shell, Poplawski dark-energy claim explicitly engaged and closed via Route 1, all 14 barriers source

v2L.0.1: first draft. Rescoped from P2 v1.7.130 per PORTFOLIO_DECISION_2026-09-02.md Sec.3 Track A A1, unblocked by NEXT_SCIENCE_LEDGER.md #1 (CLOSED 2026-09-02: independent from-scratch in-in reproduces f_NL=-35/16, Cai et al. 2009 -35/8 l

R1 closure: 42 finding-rows audited (Claude INT major-revisions, Grok API REJECT, Gemini API REJECT), 19 canonical real items closed via real edits. Grown from Note to Paper form (10pp/7725 words). 4-pass compile, 0 undef refs, 0 overfull h

R1 closure: all 19 truth-audited items closed — three regressions restored verbatim from P1C v1C.0.16; Popławski identification rescoped to exact evidential strength (γ→∞ identity; ×0.053 suppression and 2.11× trace-vector ratio at γ=0.2375

R1 closure: 18/20 truth-audited items closed — self-contained catalog paper (schema, selection function, completeness/purity, released-classifier confusion matrix, estimator + covariance, injection-recovery, void-definition ladder); consist

First folded draft: P4 8.47M-galaxy catalog + P5 DESIVAST environment section folded in, plus new Sec.5 Poplawski black-hole-universe spin-axis exclusion (eta>0.98% at >=95% coverage) per PORTFOLIO_DECISION_2026-09-02.md Track C1 Addendum.

First merged draft (P1A algebraic elimination + P1C 14-entry no-go survey) into one <=12pp gr-qc/CQG Note per PORTFOLIO_DECISION_2026-09-02.md Track B. 4-pass compile 0 undef refs, 0 overfull hboxes, 4/4 consistency-check rules PASS. No INT

Close exact-final viewer binding, denominator, deduplication specification, and checkpoint digest findings without changing catalog membership.

Close exact-final viewer binding, denominator, deduplication specification, and checkpoint digest findings without changing catalog membership.

Bind viewer captures and correct checkpoint, dedup, and exclusion accounting

Bind viewer captures and correct checkpoint, dedup, and exclusion accounting

Expand Expected Calibration Error (ECE) at first use; no scientific claim, number, or caveat changed.

Adopt evidence-bounded r16 control and viewer closure

Withdraw unsupported annular-deficit mechanism; add core-conditioned audit; restore exact r2 Parquet; narrow viewer-capture evidence.

Close exact-final Gemini descriptive-wording finding

AJ AASTeX 7.0.2 line-numbered journal-shell migration and layout closure; no science change

AASTeX 7.0.2 package and table-caption artifact-link overflow closure; no science change

AASTeX 7.0.2 line-numbered portal package, short title, verified ORCID, and evidence-bounded AI-use disclosure; no science change

MINOR: 'rate' wording imprecise (non-material)

JORS submission-gate closure: the previously undispositioned 2026-07-23 Grok [MAJOR] is closed. Its literal irreconcilable-contradiction claim is FALSIFIED (pyproject.toml, codemeta.json, CITATION.cff, __init__.py and Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.

Target-program leakage prominence: abstract caveat clause, new Limitations bullet, and Conclusions conditionality sentence closing the remedy half of the 2026-07-23 Gemini [MAJOR] on Sec VI.E.d. Prose only; zero reported numbers changed.

Gate 1: relocated raw SHA-256 digests, immutable revisions, and bare artifact filenames out of the primary narrative into a new artifact provenance register (Table tab:artifact_provenance, A1-A12) + Data Availability, closing the twice-dism

Estimator-hierarchy sensitivity consolidation: new tab:hierarchy_sensitivity in sec:primary_path placing the focal released-parent estimate beside the two demoted any-hole estimates; all values transcribed from existing tables/artifacts, no

PRD submission-gate closure: AI Usage Disclosure section added (APS requires disclosure of substantive AI use in the submitted paper, with tool name/version, how it assisted, and how the author directed and verified it); deposit self-refere

ApJS abstract cut 426->249 words (AAS 250-word cap); deposit self-reference made drift-proof via computed patch delta (pattern-047)

PRD submission-gate closure: AI Usage Disclosure section added (APS requires disclosure of substantive AI use in the submitted paper, with tool name/version, how it assisted, and how the author directed and verified it); deposit self-refere

CQG submission-gate closure: Note-scoped acknowledgments carrying IOP-mandatory competing-interests, funding, and generative-AI declarations now compile (previously trapped inside the comment block); Data and Code Availability promoted to i

v0.1.144 — companion-status back-patch: the rendered Paper II bibliography reference now cites the published Zenodo record (version DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21461881, concept 10.5281/zenodo.21461880, deposited 2026-07-20, CC-BY-4.0) with its exac

v1.7.129 — companion-status back-patch: the rendered Paper I A bibliography reference now cites the published Zenodo record (version DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21481838, concept 10.5281/zenodo.21481837, deposited 2026-07-22, CC-BY-4.0) with its exa

re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense

re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense

re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense

confirmation-board closures: Table 5 excluded-rows label, epoch-5-breakout/epoch-47-best wording, abstract parity-bound hardening

confirmation-board closures: Zenodo tense truthful convention, shifted-annulus deficit stated honestly with in-paper mechanism, version-tag key completed

confirmation-board closures: Zenodo tense truthful convention, shifted-annulus deficit stated honestly with in-paper mechanism, version-tag key completed

confirmation-board transparency closures: prior labeled illustrative benchmark, r_eff clause, 0.36sigma, 34.7% baseline aligned, 2.63sigma recompute wording

confirmation-board closures: Paper-II bibitem cited in Sec I (back-patch anchor retained), monopole significance harmonized to 9.5sigma

confirmation-board closures: archival DOI in active availability section; Fierz attribution both-named; NJL torsion operator cross-note

confirmation-board closures: Overview stub removed, null-injection realization count anchored, stale blocker sentence dropped

DOI embed: manuscript archival deposit 10.5281/zenodo.21481842 cited in Archive paragraph alongside software DOI (Houston publish-go 2026-07-21)

DOI embed: published archival deposit 10.5281/zenodo.21481838 cited in availability paragraph (Houston publish-go 2026-07-21)

Archive closure: namaster-proof 0.1.7 bound to published Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21481753; persistent-identifier submission blocker closed

Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461899 version / 21461898 concept) at abstract + Data Availability + release itemize; submission-time placeholder replaced; systematics-metadata sidecar gate honestly kept open. DOI gate CLOSED

Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461888 version / 21461887 concept) in Data Availability with the honest self-deposited-vs-AAS-journal-DOI distinction; the AAS digital-asset DOI stays an open journal gate. Archival DOI gate CL

Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461881 version / 21461880 concept); Data-and-Code-Availability deferral replaced with the published deposit description; honest archived-bytes distinction stated. DOI gate CLOSED.

CE-composition adjudication + honest negative integrated: Jia catalog re-provisioned (Zenodo DOI, sha-verified); GZ1 6,637 + CE-spiral 17,153 reproduced exactly, reproducible non-spiral = 819 — conflict isolated to the seeded subsample cros

Phase-2 pod-campaign integration: 4x4 joint covariance (MASTER-decoupled Cl1 z=-0.61, proxy validation rho=+0.943, BLAS caveat) closes the pod-bound refinement; G4 monopole mechanism over 16.9M banked forward passes — classifier confusion e

Dressed-metric transmission closure integrated: the bounded bounce is transparent to the conserved mode in the dressed-metric scheme (T_c(k)=1; |delta f_NL| <= 6.8e-8 at k*eta_B=1e-2 — more than four orders below the prior OOM reference), w

G1+G2 real-compute closures integrated: manifest-retained retrain (val_acc 0.9931, every ID/split/seed retained, 3-location backed up) and training-disjoint validation (acc 0.9867, kappa 0.9733 on 3000 doubly-disjoint GZ1 spirals) added wit

Three truth-audited framing/citation closures on the Eq-5 torsion paragraph: reframed from 'bound/quantified' to an explicit order-of-magnitude parametric estimate with the energy-density transfer proxy stated as asserted (not derived in-in

Model-specific torsion bound computed and integrated: Eq 5 bounds |delta f_NL^tor| via the P1A-anchored Einstein-Cartan four-fermion contact term (prefactor saturation 0.022-0.21 within EFT validity; <<1e-3 for sub-Planckian abundance; n_ps

Coverage-calibrated observed-label 95% upper limit computed and integrated: A_95^obs ~ 0.98% via 2000 random-axis injections/amplitude through the exact committed primary estimator and 10^4-draw fixed-occupancy null (headline reproduced exa

G3 joint estimator covariance integrated: new Sec 4.5 + Table 9 present the N=2000 block-bootstrap 3x3 dipole/WLS/monopole covariance (monopole z=-6.57 the only |z|>3 mode, correlations -0.037/-0.093 with the dipole estimators); six caveat

Two one-sentence closures from the exact v2B.0.10 board truth audit: explicit pytest invocation command in Sec 7 QC; explicit non-affiliation sentence (independent downstream verification layer, not an official NaMaster release) in Sec 11.

Integrity reframe of the CONFIRMED circularity finding: the sub-0.1-arcsec core (170 matches) is restated everywhere (abstract, Sec 3.5, Fig 1 caption, Sec 7, Sec 8) as expected seed self-recovery — an end-to-end recovery verification, not

Optional polish closures from the v2B.0.9 truth audit: workspace-tensor regenerability surfaced in Sec 7 with a new examples/rebuild_workspace_check.py recheck script (skip-safe without PyMaster), real committed execution-cost figures (701.

Claude-leg truth-audit closures: package 0.1.7 adds skipif guards to the 2 monorepo-coupled replay tests (41 pass in monorepo, 39+2-skip standalone, verified both ways), codemeta.json added, JORS availability template completed (system requ

Claude-leg truth-audit editorial closures: torsion-vanishing lemma now shows the 4D contraction coefficients (derived from the manuscript's own identities and hand-verified), Sec III.B relabeled mean-field NJL diagnostic with claim-scope so

Bounded editorial closures from the Claude-leg truth audit: machinery-as-primary-deliverable sentences in abstract + Sec 1, version-tag lineage footnote, tab:examples full-precision note for the two -0.000 redshifts, BigAE-stream copy edit.

Forward-leakage injection closure: new semi-analytic forward model [A47]/[A48] predicts each large raw deviation from committed per-program/imaging-leg leakage components through the measured env-by-program contingency — reproducing 77-88%

Closes the single genuinely-new-real item from the exact v1.0.262 board truth audit: the Appendix-B quarantine stability value (z=+0.48 excluded vs +0.52 baseline, c11b 10^4-perm) is now surfaced in the main-Results post-hoc-disclosure para

Closes both genuinely-new-real v1.0.261 truth-audit findings: (Ge2) plain-English raw_flip_qc_unsafe gloss at first main-text declaration; (C4) delivered per-region CW-fraction monopole correction map with binomial uncertainty (NSIDE=8 and

Whole-tree global-multiplicity closure: adds family-wise-corrected significance for the most extreme deviation across the entire declared analysis tree (N=23 paths, p_min=0.0357 bright-vs-dark filament sign-flip, Bonferroni p_global<=0.822,

ROUND_2026-07-16-P5-v0.1.139-EXACTPDF-948e0412-CLAUDESTACK-CONFIRM · reviewers: grok-4.3 (xAI direct API): MINOR REVISIONS, gemini-3.1-pro-preview (Google direct API): MINOR REVISIONS, claude-opus subagent (Anthropic subscription): MAJOR REVISIONS, codex: ABSENT (paused, directive N)

Immutable provider overlay published: strict-primary overlay public at HF revision 911316f31c21f2c4b933a2f3a761274cfe85c6d6 (apjs-release/v1.0.259-strict-primary), all 7 files remote-byte-verified; data-availability/manifest/conclusions tex

Enforce recursive JSON-type-strict metadata validation and exact finite decouple-cell output shapes; package 0.1.6 with 41 tests.

Reject non-integral public multipole inputs without coercion; add seven boundary regressions; package 0.1.5.

Reject non-integral public multipole inputs without coercion; add seven boundary regressions; package 0.1.5.

Close v2B.0.5 confirmation regression: restore sharded-validation section placement, correct beta_rad API example, and add archived-monorepo package isolation instructions; readiness remains 56.

Close exact-board JSON strictness, CI trigger, mask-coordinate, CRediT, and dependency-disclosure findings; readiness remains 56 pending archive, confirmation, and human review.

Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.

Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.

Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.

Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.

Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.

Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.

Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.

Close confirmation-board residuals; add retained real-PyMaster integration benchmark and regression coverage; clarify receipt and production-threshold claims.

Truth-audited confirmation closure: real PyMaster benchmark, current supersession state, corrected tolerance semantics, direct artifact links, and protected-field receipt wording; readiness holds 56.

Truth-audited first-board closure with full-hash typography fix: fail-closed inputs, 23 tests, narrowed provenance claims, JORS structure; readiness holds 56.

Truth-audited first-board closure: fail-closed spectrum/statistical inputs, 23 tests, narrowed content-binding guarantees, corrected physical artifacts, and JORS structure; readiness holds 56 pending confirmation and archive.

Major publication-architecture correction: focused namaster-proof 0.1.0 software metapaper; mirror-discovery regression closed; readiness holds 56 pending exact review.

Major publication-architecture correction: replace the rejected standalone JCAP companion with the focused namaster-proof 0.1.0 software metapaper; 19 tests and independent example; readiness holds 56 pending exact review.

Truth-audited v1B.0.111 closure: bind active BBN prose to executed PRIMAT table, distinguish mean-bandpower and realization-level NaMaster estimators, correct cosine-flat angular-prior median, and repair equation overflow; readiness holds 5

Truth-audited v1B.0.111 closure: bind active BBN prose to executed PRIMAT table, distinguish mean-bandpower and realization-level NaMaster estimators, and correct cosine-flat angular-prior median; readiness holds 56 pending confirmation.

Physical CAMB NaMaster 500-MC production and eight-configuration robustness suite completed; version-matched immutable manifest retained; readiness held pending exact re-review and human review.

Recompute the DES-Y3 S8 overlay from the frozen chains with the declared 30% burn-in; bind raw/post-burn sample counts and artifact hashes; correct the claims-table layout for current REVTeX; readiness remains 56 pending corrected NaMaster

Bind manuscript Data Availability to the exact strict-primary overlay while retaining the immutable catalog revision and honestly recording provider publication and DOI as open gates.

Close residual confirmation synchronization defects in primary audit table, harmonic null moments, mask contract, and public-release disclosure.

Close unanimous minor residual findings on interaction wording, pooled-reference covariance, T-Web count provenance, and deterministic ordering.

Eliminate isolated arXiv equation overflow in focal-model specification; no scientific result changed.

Promote full-rank K13 focal hierarchy; add cluster robustness and bounded program-interaction sensitivity

Exact safe-primary and common-support harmonic closure; systematics diagnostic remains non-cosmological

Close exact-PDF v0.1.135 confirmation findings: promote rank-defensible K=13 focal inference; repair classifier/release provenance and figure labels; Paper IV/archive/human-review gates remain.

Close exact-PDF v1.0.256 confirmation findings: correct two-declination-proxy scope and remove causal TTA overclaim; standing validation/metadata/archive gates remain.

Exact-PDF recursive truth-audit closure: relabel focal hybrid; add deterministic reduced-rank CR1 and wild-cluster inference; correct multiplicity and target-program language.

Exact-PDF truth-audit closure: synchronize primary provenance; correct LEE and diagnostic-null descriptions, historical bias-test metrics, and unsupported causal/spatial language.

proactive portfolio preflight removed a false frozen-artifact claim and bounded A39/A40 to the GALZONE/VoidFinder control; no scientific result changed

close exact-board release-integrity findings with row-level quarantine identity proof, portable bootstrap, and bounded model/manuscript wording

Truth-audited Catalog B scope correction, immutable source-count disclosure, and public Catalog C semantic-contract publication

Close verified HF release-contract defects with immutable dataset/model revisions; readiness remains 80 pending standing science, DOI, and human-review gates

Public release-integrity closure: correct the stale Hugging Face dataset card and publish a byte-pinned, executable one-to-one morphology join for all 3,201,160 safe-catalog spiral rows. Primary HC result unchanged; readiness 80 holds pendi

Truth-audited bounded closure of the exact v1.0.250 board: correct WLS support, confusion-transfer wording, add-one MC tails, schema binding, bibliography order, and presentation. Primary HC result unchanged; readiness 80 holds pending trai

P4 v1.0.250 AASTeX 7.0.1 presentation closure: converted the canonical manuscript to the target ApJS class with two-column line-numbered layout and numeric citations; removed the nonstandard table-of-contents and revtex-only constructs; com

Exact-v1.0.248 MAJOR/MINOR/MAJOR truth-audit closure. Restricts the FS-C synthesis to apodization robustness and multipole coherence after verifying that quartile, leg-proxy, boundary-distance, density-null, WLS/bootstrap, and direct-cross-

Exact-v1.0.247 MAJOR/MINOR/MINOR board truth-audit closure. Corrected the public primary-null bundle at immutable HF data commit db110233 / receipt e535b262; excluded historical WLS/bootstrap and +3.80 sigma density-null diagnostics from th

Public commit-pinned ApJS catalog bundle plus exact GZ1 supported-N closure; training, covariance, DOI-backed paper archive, exact review, and human review remain open.

Bounded truth-audit closure of the exact v1.0.245 board: corrected all primary fixed-occupancy-null anchors and selected-versus-supported accounting; replaced the uniform-dilution shortcut with the full two-class confusion transfer; disclos

Truth-audited v1.0.244 review closure: exchangeability-safe fixed-occupancy label shuffle is primary (z=0.7053169638, p=0.2246775322); former pixel permutation retained as robustness; training and GZ1 provenance corrected; public-title clai

Truth-audited v1B.0.108 review closure: retained 100,000-draw-per-arm spectator-conditioned ALP prior-predictive artifact; corrected executed NaMaster and S8 grids, weighted posterior summaries, and unsupported full-EB forecast; exact v1B.0

Retained local DESIVAST catalog-native void non-detection candidate with corrected bounded release language; immutable public archive and human review remain open.

Bounded ApJS release candidate with safe schema, compact release, deterministic primary-null reproduction, and retained transfer and selection limits. No v244 re-review.

ApJS public-ID recovery release candidate r8 with bounded association tiers, clean-checkout validation, and no purity, novelty, or detection claim.

Bounded convention-and-clarity closure on the exact contraction-phase result; automated exact-PDF board ACCEPT across subscription Codex and direct Gemini/Grok, not journal acceptance.

Bounded confirmation closure: truthful synthetic native-coordinate window description, rendered N=100000 prior-predictive method, and 195-artifact provenance inventory. No v108 re-review.

Compact exact-artifact CQG Note closure; subscription-backed Codex review returned ACCEPT, but human, archive, and venue gates remain open.

M24-EXT DP4-22 close: edge-on Appendix-E sensitivity penalty corrected sqrt->linear ((1-d)^-1=18.8% not (1-d)^-1/2=9.0%; naive f_CW estimator retains edge-on in N_spiral -> linear dilution). Both call sites + b/a sweep + artifact JSON updat

M28-INT genuinely-new: artifact-ID range descriptors [A1]--[A32] corrected to [A1]--[A34] at 3 in-PDF sites (acknowledgments + Appendix C numbering note) + caption path-enumeration updated for A33/A34; the RSD artifacts appended in v0.1.122

Reconcile current to v1.0.239 (main/Codex state). The v1.0.240 edge-on penalty fix (DP4-22) is parked on branch tick-p4-dp4-22-edgeon-2026-07-13 pending owner integration; this tick collided with a concurrent Codex driver and yielded per th

M24-EXT (2026-07-13): GENUINELY-NEW correctness item from ChatGPT-EXT M24 (edge-on sensitivity penalty). Appendix E derived the edge-on floor inflation via a Fisher-variance scaling (1-delta)^-1/2 = 8.98%, but the primary dipole uses the NA

M22-EXT: fixed a genuinely-new Data-Availability internal self-contradiction (Gaia block release + LAMOST headline-count status) named by ChatGPT #15, verified vs live .tex; wording-only, no count changed (DP3-21). streak reset 8->0.

PRD-format abstract rewrite (final standing editable item; content relocated, zero claims changed)

DP3-15 held-out re-inference: quantify pod-block (~1.3% re-pullable) + demonstrate committed 5-seed ensemble reproduces native-scale MSE axis + injrec gate; no headline number changed

M2 seven->eight term-count fix (reader-visible arithmetic-label defect; no number changed)

immutable reviewable release: RELEASE_MANIFEST.json + pinned HF tag p3-v3.1.157 (573b5da7) in DAS both variants; INT-caught consistency fixes

immutable reviewable release: RELEASE_MANIFEST.json + pinned HF revision 34319c7 in DAS both variants

v1.0.238: directive-L compute closer — full 8.47M image-level end-to-end mirror-flip injection performed through production ViT (T_raw=0.2303, T_eq=0.9997); closes ChatGPT DP4-15/Gemini image-level pseudo-label-independence MAJOR

v0.1.125: M1 wave overhaul-introduced fix — abstract 'pre-declared'->'designated-primary (exploratory, not pre-registered)' (L778), resolves the Grok+ChatGPT MAJOR#1 abstract-vs-Sec.V.B contradiction the directive-M rewrite introduced; no n

Directive-L compute closer FOLDED: full image-level end-to-end mirror-flip injection performed on all 8.47M galaxies through the production ViT — T_raw=0.2303±0.0002 (stable across confidence bins + N/S strata); Z2-TTA labeling exactly pari

DP1U overhaul + H0/MPl exponent consistency fix (10^-60 -> 10^-61 at L2639, matching L3322/L3808; true value 1.2e-61) — INT-Claude MINOR closed in-round

presentation completion: PRD abstract; strip guide/rebuttal residue; systematics-budget sum as multline (fix hbox); byte-preserved numbers

DP1U presentation overhaul (overflow fix pass)

presentation completion: single PRD-format abstract paragraph (352->41 lines); strip reader's-guide/co-review/rebuttal residue; fix 36pt systematics-budget hbox via display eqn; content byte-preserved

DP1U presentation overhaul: abstract repetition purge + barrier-catalog consolidation to description-list with route map + appendix E/F/G supplementary reframe; all numbers byte-preserved, zero physics change

directive-M presentation restructure; zero content change; -35/16 untouched

presentation completion: single PRD-format abstract paragraph (352->41 lines); strip reader's-guide/co-review-request/rebuttal-note residue; content byte-preserved

directive-M presentation overhaul: PRD single-paragraph abstract (5 paras ~430w -> 1 para ~230w, byte-preserving all numbers) + de-dup 'sigma not comparable' caveat (removed 4 per-figure parentheticals + trimmed 2 table captions to one stat

NJ4 INT-Claude MINOR closed: leg-(B) magnitude bound now explicitly covers attractive AA channel (worst |G_AA|/G_crit=2x0.156=0.31); AA/PP flagged not-the-scalar-condensate so scalar sign leg already decisive; far->plain sub-critical in abs

RSD estimand relabel (unrestricted) + sign fix + quadrature 0.898

INT-Claude leg-A scalar-channel scope fix + far->comfortably sub-critical

INT-Claude genuinely-new MAJOR closed by RE-COMPUTE: the c15 channel-native joint {f_NL,b_phi,A_GR} Fisher built the GR-projection derivative dB/dA_GR = b*b*b*S_GR WITHOUT the M123=M(k1)M(k2)M(k3) transfer product the f_NL primordial leg (b

CN1: c15 GR channel-native result demoted (potential-vs-density metric mismatch -> A_GR Fisher weight vacuous; overstated-proxy claim deleted); headline proxy floor unchanged (INT-Claude CN1r catch)

NJ1: Holst NJL factor 30x->14x per committed njl_gap script (INT-Claude catch); conclusion unchanged

directive-L closure DP5-12: RSD first-order Zel'dovich reconstruction bound integrated (shift 0.024pp, ~40x under 0.9pp envelope, null preserved)

Route-1 vacuum condensate excluded by regulated NJL gap-equation analysis (repulsive channel + sub-critical coupling)

channel-native joint {f_NL,b_phi,A_GR} bispectrum Fisher (c15) closes DP2 proxy-floor MAJOR by adopting the c13 tree-level Gaussian MT covariance surrogate; channel-native rho(f_NL,A_GR)=-0.001, floor 2.5sigma > proxy 1.3sigma

FR3 INT-Claude wave-2 truth-audit closure (DP3-19): 1 genuinely-new reader-visible correctable finding -> clean-wave streak RESET 1 -> 0. (1) matter-bounce NANOGrav parameter-shift precision made CONSISTENT with the v3.1.154 SMBHB fix: the

DP3-19: matter-bounce parameter-shift +1.13σ→+1.14σ consistency with the v3.1.154 full-precision SMBHB +4.63σ fix (chain 1.13543); F_0 0.01239→0.01240 (downstream 0.01509→0.01510; σ=8.14 unchanged). 2 genuinely-new INT-Claude items verified

FR1 closure: NANOGrav SMBHB +4.61->+4.63 sigma misround fix (4 sites); DP3-18

restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)

restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)

restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)

restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)

restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)

W3-INT confirm wave: dedicated v0.1.118/119/120 changelog block of record for the void-stratum integration (was previously only a retro-annotation on the v0.1.116 block); comment-only, no reader-visible change [Claude W3-INT MINOR#1]

close missed de-attenuation site: void measurement now cited in §XII-B (predecessor closure completed)

close missed XII-B de-attenuation site — void measurement now cited (predecessor mid-flight closure completed)

W1-INT: propagate v1U.0.11 Check D fix (-3/8 J5.J5) to dim4_parityodd_enumeration.py + abstract eps-eps=-3!delta; Claude INT MAJOR closed (artifact/abstract sync per directive-I6)

re-mirror: heal 3-way served-PDF divergence caught by verify-only (no content change)

Claude-referee presentation closures: PRD abstract, proxy-floor disclosure, certify-framing, cite fixes

Claude-referee presentation closures: PRD abstract, proxy-floor disclosure, certify-framing, cite fixes

void-stratified confusion measurement integrated (closes last OPEN-COMPUTE recipe item)

H17F Grok-minor closures: DAS repo pointer, abstract rephrase, clarity items

Re-assert v0.1.117 as current (directive-G validation re-run had re-inserted a v0.1.116 row with newer createdAt, stealing the tie-break).

directive-G script validation re-run

directive-G script validation re-run

directive-G script validation re-run

directive-G script validation re-run

H17 loop iter-2: closed the one genuinely-new Claude-ACCEPT cosmetic nit - corrected imprecise 'disjoint subsamples' to 'distinct (nested) subsamples' (the confident-spiral stratified set is a high-confidence subset of, not disjoint from, t

directive-G script validation re-run

directive-G script validation re-run

H17 INT re-test closure: closed 3 genuinely-new Claude-subagent MINORs on the v1.0.233 sky/confidence-stratified confusion analysis (Appendix B). Softened Sec IV C cannot-manufacture phrasing to corroborates-but-does-not-fully-close; added

H17 retest2 close: fixed two stale primary=+0.0007 labels to promoted footprint-restricted +0.0018 (n_void=57,081); sharpened 2a-1 symmetry claim to adjacent-strata-not-void-axis + accuracy-reconciliation sentence (0.912 vs 0.699); repointe

v1.0.233 (H17 science upgrade): new Appendix-B subsection Sky- and confidence-stratified human-label confusion analysis + Table tab:gz1_stratified (5 strata: overall/BASS+MzLS/DECaLS/science-cut/low-conf; N, acc, CW->CCW / CCW->CW, asymmetr

H17 cross-paper integration: committed GZ1-overlap stratified human-vs-classifier CW/CCW confusion matrix (pipelines/p2_chirality/outputs/gz1_stratified_confusion.json, commit 84d53b75) integrated into the recurring 'no environment-stratifi

H17 EXT re-test closure: ChatGPT Check-D MAJOR (genuinely-new internal inconsistency) fixed. Check D (Appendix) and the O4/O5 reduction printed S_abc S^abc = 6(J5.J5) using eps_abcd eps^abce = +3! and dropping the (1/4)^2=1/16 from S=(1/4)e

H17 INT re-test: 4 editable Claude MINORs closed vs committed artifacts (abstract sign-gloss reword; continuous-marg BF 4.8->4.6 reconciled to c9k 4.615; tab:gr -35/8 refs 3.5e8/4.5e5/6.4e2->3.0e8/4.2e5/6.1e2; c9k/c9g stale metadata refresh

H17 re-test v1.0.231->v1.0.232: closed 3 INT MINORs (Claude retest) — stale z=-18 straggler in Primary-Results callout caption (816) -> z=-7.6; stale naive-WLS z=-264.5 in WLS table caption (1370) -> z=-112 (both post-Shamir-correction stra

H17 INT re-test (v3.1.151) truth-audit: 1 VERIFIED-NEW editable fix (INT-Claude MAJOR#1 headline 37.3M scan-volume bookkeeping) closed via reconciliation footnote (no new numbers); INT-OpenAI/Grok-API REJECTs reviewed stale v3.1.144 (re-fla

H17 ChatGPT EXT addendum: corrected the stale tab:gr BF-vs-SSFSR column + P(BF>3) + sigma_GR=0.05 calibration + continuous-marginalization SSFSR + tab:bayes SSFSR column, all of which were still at the superseded -35/8 center while the Tune

H17 second closure: 57,081 exact-count primary made single primary everywhere (abstract/title/intro/§XV); k=20 56,981 confined to labeled sensitivity-control rows. New consolidated Bonferroni-5 family table (all 5 rows, common sign conventi

H17 closures: primary estimand unified to footprint-restricted exact +0.0018; Table X exact-count block; GALZONE text matched to code; Data Availability Statement added.

H17 closures: three-gate framing honestly downgraded (production gate + correlated proxy checks); provenance reconciliations (37.3M read/scored; 195,790 vs 195,829 DESI); per-survey cut definitions clarified.

H17 round P2 closure: corrected Cai spurious-term sign to -(99/128)Sum k^3 and the printed-polynomial->-35/8 mechanism claim (both inconsistent with committed scripts; transcribed A_T reduces to -305/64, not Cai's stated -35/8) per Grok EXT

H17: Shamir factor-of-2 fix. Shamir's 1.7%-4.0% is a full-count asymmetry (N_CW-N_CCW)/(N_CW+N_CCW) identical to A_p, so A_ref 0.034->0.017, block-bootstrap z -18.1->-7.6, tension 7-18x->3.7-8.8x. Every text site + WLS table + bootstrap fig

H17 ChatGPT-EXT truth-audit: 3 VERIFIED-NEW editable fixes (residual three-gate framing at contributions list relabeled to single production-gate; Planck top-1% header clarified as 0.10% of native bank; 195,790-vs-195,829 primary-coadd gap

H17 truth-audit closure: (b) relabeled the vector-axial four-fermion Holst partner as arising only under NON-MINIMAL coupling per Freidel-Minic-Takeuchi (PRD 72 104002) - minimal coupling gives only the axial-axial R1 term; fixed the abstra

H17 INT-Claude integrity closure (VERIFIED-NEW, not a re-flag): the two fold-based DESI gates (5-fold Jaccard 0.862, held-out tail-preservation rho=1.00) are computed from the SAME per-fold score vectors of short-trained proxy models that F

H17 round: fixed primary-estimand inconsistency (Conclusions now lead footprint-restricted +0.0018 as primary, matching abstract/VIIIB); added exact-membership void row (57081/28339) to Table X so +0.0018 reproduces from integer counts; cla

G15 closure: Bonferroni-5-first framing + de-attenuated 2.26pp physical bound + App B non-covariant-EFT hardening. Presentation-only.

G15 closure: z-18 template-disfavor caveat + 47pct remainder<A50 sentence + Shamir mechanism context + Fig10 caption. Presentation-only.

G15 closure: MCMC-envelope reframe + Eq.6 mass-dimension presentation + Grok/ChatGPT minors. Presentation-only, no verified number changed.

F14 closure: end-to-end transfer-calibration scope statement; asymmetric-confusion slope g_eff=s_CW+s_CCW-1=0.398 equals symmetric g=2a-1; image-level end-to-end injection honest-flagged as new simulation. No number changed.

F14 closure: R4 spectator-ALP framing sharpened (ECH-specific rigid-coupling 22-36 OOM overshoot vs generic m_theta~H_0 quintessence tuning). No number changed.

F14 closure: dual-primary reconciled (footprint-restricted +0.0018 primary, unrestricted +0.0007 secondary), footprint!=selection-function distinction, 0.9pp quadrature term-sum, simultaneous Bonferroni-5 bound (|df_CW|<~1.1pp). No verified

F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini

F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini

F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini

F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini

F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini

Process-leak scrub (no number changed, nothing fabricated). Two body-text sentences that referenced the internal review process were rewritten as standalone scientific prose: the Sec II A 2 dimension-4 operator-bookkeeping paragraph now sta

CV-round (2026-07-09) EXT closure: framing/relocation of the harmonic residual (below recovery threshold, origin unresolved — not 'non-cosmological'), hemisphere-LEE recast (rejects random-label null but attributed to systematics), GZ1 huma

CV-round (2026-07-09) EXT closure: framing/relocation of the harmonic residual (below recovery threshold, origin unresolved — not 'non-cosmological'), hemisphere-LEE recast (rejects random-label null but attributed to systematics), GZ1 huma

CV-round EXT closure (framing/figure only, 0 verified numbers changed): (B1) new consolidated per-survey provenance Table in §III (public-archive -> read/scored -> thresholded -> count-retained -> tier), reproduced from existing values only

CV-round EXT closure (2026-07-09; ChatGPT MAJOR-revisions reopened off CA ACCEPT, Grok/Gemini MINOR). Framing/relocation only; every verified number unchanged EXCEPT the stated systematic envelope, which was WIDENED (never tightened). B1: h

W12 EXT presentation closure. NO headline number changed (-35/16 UNCHANGED), nothing fabricated. Closed the presentation majors: Grok MegaMapper Fig-2 headlining (scoped as future/Stage-V, SPHEREx range headlined) + endpoint-language drift

W12 EXT presentation-closure: neutral tone on Cai et al. (arithmetic error->one identified discrepancy), stale MegaMapper 3-7sigma->1.5-3.85sigma, GR-bracket disclosure in abstract (~0.8-2.75sigma), Table V relabeled scenario/scoping budget

W12 EXT closure. Dimensional truth-audit: ChatGPT RIGHT — the bare Table-VII invariants O1/O2/O4/O6 are naive dim-2, not dim-4, so 'dimensionless c_n' was a main-text transcription slip (appendix derivation was correct). Fixed: new Eq.(dim4

CA-round ChatGPT-4-MAJOR closure: NEOWISE mixed-validation label, SecI science-target/native-threshold reader-guide, at-submission reproducibility commitment; no verified number changed

CA-round polish closure: filament program-row split, boxed real-vs-redshift-space Conclusions callout; no science number changed

CA-round polish closure: Table V reader-note, abstract not-a-loophole line, exact qc_flip filter cmd, CW/ACW->CCW; no science number changed

W11 EXT presentation-closure: calibrated -35/16 claim to exact vertex-sum+Li framing, made SPHEREx additive-quadrature budget an explicit displayed equation, labeled MegaMapper decisively uncalibrated high-z, fixed stale f_NL~-4. -35/16 unc

W11 EXT presentation-closure: formal dim-4 off-shell operator into main-text Eq.6 (new Eq.7, closed O1-O6 basis, dim-+1 = on-shell shorthand, App B.1 cross-ref) = THE ask; Grok polish list closed. No number changed.

W11 EXT presentation-closure: calibrated abstract to vertex re-summation yields -35/16 exactly + Li independent derivation decisively favors it (ChatGPT claim-strength; algebraic map already displayed); made SPHEREx additive-quadrature budg

W11 EXT presentation-closure: brought the formally dim-4 off-shell parity-odd operator into the main text at Eq.6 (new Eq.7, closed O1-O6 basis; dim-+1 = on-shell presentation shorthand, App B.1 cross-ref) = THE ask (ChatGPT B2 + Gemini Blo

W10 accept-track closure: 268,519-validated sole headline, NEOWISE geometry-QA validation-basis disclosure elevated, SDSS continuity-slice threshold clarity, DESI 2,468 science-target foregrounded, cosmology sections scoped as demonstration

W10 accept-track minor closure: post-hoc caveat to abstract headline, definition-family-null framing for void-membership bound, RSD redshift-space clarifier in abstract and Conclusions, Paper IV co-review contingency sentence, sensitivity-e

W10 accept-track minor closure: ChatGPT/Grok/Gemini polish minors (incommensurable-σ table note, GZ1-null-test scope, ~47% residual future-approach, A95 conservative-grid label, injection axis convention, parity-sector context, A_p footnote

REAL-WORK closure of v1U.0.3 EXT majors: DERIVED the genuine local dim-4 parity-odd operator completion (App B, Table VII O1-O6, symbolic-verified script; single-scale NDA closure survives at dim 4 without on-shell dressing), WROTE OUT the

R9 ACCEPT-track minor closure: Grok=minor-revisions, Gemini=Accept-with-minor-revisions; both referees concrete minors closed with real edits (no number changed). Abstract z-18 now explicitly a model-dependent template-disfavor statistic (n

R9 closure: per-vertex term-by-term derivation table (App A Table VII) walking each of Cai's four cubic vertices through squeezed+equilateral limits (fNL summing exact-fraction to -35/16 / -255/128, transcribed verbatim from committed sympy

R9 EXT closure: held-out anomaly-tail-preservation OOS test (rho=1.00+/-0.05, min 0.94, gate>=0.5 PASS) directly answers the in-sample-scoring major; main-text 5,384 QSO-candidate tracer selection added (Grok minor). No count changed, nothi

R9 closure: consolidated next-leading-systematics budget (each sub-dominant to 0.34-0.37pp membership term, 0.5-0.6pp envelope unchanged); DR2 pre-registration commitment; Paper-IV coordinated co-review request unmissable at flag site; T-We

P1U EXT closure wave: Gemini 2 MINORs closed (parity-odd terminology clarity at Sec IV D/Footnote 3 + companion non-load-bearing disclosure made unmissable); Grok MAJORs dispositioned (self-disclosed scope / falsified-vs-source). No number

P1U INT merge-seam closure: (SEAM1) companion-framing of now-internal appendices rewritten to an honest Result-provenance map; (SEAM2) dangling 'Table I' sample-count ref fixed — 309,189 raw accepted samples VERIFIED from committed chains (

P1U INT merge-seam closure: (SEAM1) companion-framing of now-internal appendices rewritten to an honest Result-provenance map; (SEAM2) dangling 'Table I' sample-count ref fixed — 309,189 raw accepted samples VERIFIED from committed chains (

UNIFIED PAPER 1: P1B merged into P1A per unanimous reviewer recommendation (Houston-approved 2026-07-08). P1A v1A.0.115 body + proven-Fierz appendix + P1B v1B.0.104 as appendices (MCMC/DeltaN_eff methodology, NaMaster validation, ALP prior-

Deep-Grok MAJOR closure: displayed Appendix-A vertex algebra (collapsed exact vertex-sum degree-9 polynomial + epsilon-order-grouped squeezed contributions -5/2,+5/16,0 -> -35/16), transcribed verbatim from committed sympy certification scr

Deep-tier Gemini MAJOR closure: self-contained training-provenance table + probabilistic-calibration paragraph (real top-label ECE lower bound from committed GZ1 confusion matrix, ECE>=0.36 3-class / >=0.25 chirality), proven invariant to m

Deep-Grok MAJOR closure: displayed Appendix-A vertex algebra (collapsed exact vertex-sum degree-9 polynomial + epsilon-order-grouped squeezed contributions -5/2,+5/16,0 -> -35/16), transcribed verbatim from committed sympy certification scr

Deep-tier Gemini MAJOR closure: self-contained training-provenance table + probabilistic-calibration paragraph (real top-label ECE lower bound from committed GZ1 confusion matrix, ECE>=0.36 3-class / >=0.25 chirality), proven invariant to m

RSD (redshift-space) tree bispectrum Fisher (c14) applied: retires the real-space-monopole-only limitation with real computation. Kaiser Z1 + SCF99/Sefusatti Z2, growth f(z)=fsigma8/sigma8 from same CAMB Planck2018, orientation-integrated (

Pod-gated closure: EXACT spatial-uniformity chi^2 recomputed on the 377,482 post-excision headline set. Prior drafts reported chi^2=376,713 on the full inclusive 378,280 set (incl. now-excised Gaia-500 + eROSITA-298) and stated the exact re

v0.1.107 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)

v3.1.144 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)

v1B.0.104 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)

v1A.0.115 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)

FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: off REJECT, every editable item closed.

FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: all 4 Gemini MINORs closed.

FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: title reframed to anomaly-candidate catalog (268,519 unchanged).

FULL8 closure (off REJECT): LiteBIRD 9sigma/0.7sigma pairing, DNeff EFT-estimate scope, NaMaster foreground-free caveat, ALP prior-sensitivity framing, DOI note. No number changed.

FULL8 closure: all 4 Gemini MINORs closed (R4-naturalness framing, Fierz-lemma scope, NDA limitation, Sec X quantum caveat, App B heuristic). No number changed.

FULL8 closure: title reframed to anomaly-candidate catalog of reconstruction-outlier sources (268,519 unchanged); eROSITA/Gaia exclusion made unmissable. No number changed, no disclosure weakened.

Tone-regression rewrite (Gemini MAJOR): neutralized rebuttal/defensive register in Sec IX.E (signpost paragraph recast as declarative scope summary), Sec IX.E body ('We emphasize that a detection' -> neutral), Sec template ('a referee may a

Tone-regression rewrite (Gemini MAJOR): neutralized rebuttal/defensive register in Sec IX.E (signpost paragraph recast as declarative scope summary), Sec IX.E body ('We emphasize that a detection' -> neutral), Sec template ('a referee may a

FULL8 EXT closure (2026-07-08): closed all Grok+Gemini MINORs + ChatGPT editable MAJORs. Abstract headline scoped to DESIVAST void/non-void contrast + post-hoc caveat + family-wise emphasis. Conclusions: post-hoc pre-registration caveat + f

FULL8 EXT round closure (Grok+Gemini MINOR REVISIONS, ChatGPT MAJOR REVISIONS). Grok: GZ1-human-only independence cross-check forward pointer added Sec II; Table I cosmological-weight footnote; Table VII synthesis sentence. Gemini: peq>0.6

POSTPOLISH R-round visibility sharpening (presentation only; zero numbers changed): surfaced the deduplicated-by-construction disposition of ChatGPTs duplicate-coadd / non-disjoint-parent concern at the DESIVAST primary void/non-void count

POSTPOLISH R-round visibility sharpening (presentation only; no science number changed): added an impossible-to-miss bottom-line lead sentence stating the a-fortiori cosmological bound on the ~47% unmodelled l=1 residual (entire residual <

REALWORK re-test ITEM-2: sharpened Grok process-volume framing — first prose use of 268,519 now carries science-target benchmark 2,468 in the SAME sentence (process-volume vs like-for-like ~0.92x Liang2023); every headline-count use audited

REALWORK re-test ITEM-1: closed ChatGPT r=0.84 vs r_eff~0.99 apparent inconsistency — ONE crisp reconciliation at sec:spherex (r=0.84 flat-weight shape cosine = conservative recast factor; r_eff~0.99 survey-optimal squeezed-dominated amplit

Independent bispectrum Fisher built (c13): reproduces Heinrich sigma(f_NL^local)=0.626/0.687 (within 2-11%, PASSED); at the bounce template sigma(f_NL^bounce)=0.632/0.689 -> r_eff~0.99, unmarginalized 3.46/3.18 sigma for -35/16. Retires the

Independent bispectrum Fisher built (c13): from-scratch tree-level multi-tracer Fisher on the committed SPHEREx public-products table reproduces Heinrich sigma(f_NL^local)=0.626/0.687 (within 2-11%, validation PASSED); at the bounce templat

Fierz-by-Fierz projection lemma PROVEN + machine-verified (arxiv/scripts/fierz_lemma_check.py -> LEMMA PROVEN) and applied: closes the 'completeness asserted, not proven' MAJOR at the M_Pl-power-counting-class level the paper claims. New ap

v3.1.142 eROSITA tier cleanly excised (production rescaling code lost = irreproducible by provenance): 298 objects removed from every inclusive count (377,780->377,482 chain stated in-paper), released separately as reproducible membership a