VERSIONPaper 32026-07-03 16:12 PT · 47 min ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.135
RS23 confirm framing/disclosure closure (Grok genuinely-new majors): abstract 268,519 framed as process-volume (not confirmed detections) with 2,468/0.92x science-target benchmark; Section V multi-tracer f_NL softened to methodological demo
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-03 15:33 PT · 1 hr ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.134
RS22 data-integrity closure (Grok+Gemini): dropped synthetic Gaia tier entirely from catalog and all counts; eROSITA demoted to reproducible top-298 membership-only (no score-axis stats); validated headline 268,519 now DIRECTLY RECOMPUTABLE
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-03 14:44 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.97
Bespoke ECH-sector DeltaNeff (real physics upgrade): torsion-induced four-fermion (NJL) interaction integrated out of minimal Einstein-Cartan-Holst; rho_tor/rho_rad ~ (T/M_Pl)^2 gives Planck-suppressed DeltaNeff ~ 7e-45 at BBN (honest upper
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-03 14:40 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.133
v3.1.133 — eROSITA reproducible top-298 recipe (scale-invariant across 8 transforms) + Gaia tier flagged synthetic/zero-science-count (honest data-provenance disclosure); validated >=268,519 headline unaffected
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-03 14:39 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.97
Bespoke ECH-sector DeltaNeff: torsion-induced four-fermion (NJL) interaction integrated out of minimal Einstein-Cartan-Holst; rho_tor/rho_rad ~ (T/M_Pl)^2 gives Planck-suppressed DeltaNeff ~ 1e-44 at BBN. Reframes LCDM+DeltaNeff MCMC from g
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 14:31 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.103
R2 suppression grounded in verified Shapiro-Teixeira one-loop analysis (arXiv:1402.4854) — one-loop 1/(16π²) × Planck κ² × O(1) Immirzi factor; exact β(γ) still adopted, closure insensitive (≳60 orders margin).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 14:30 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.103
R2 suppression grounded in verified Shapiro-Teixeira one-loop analysis (arXiv:1402.4854) — one-loop 1/(16π²) × Planck κ² × O(1) Immirzi factor; exact β(γ) still adopted, closure insensitive (≳60 orders margin).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 14:06 PT · 2 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.102
restored VERIFIED BS β-function (arXiv:1111.0884 Eq.7, fetched+verified) — corrected earlier (γ²-1)² to (γ²-1); (23γ²+5) coeff + μ²κ² Planck-suppression verified; derived running |Δγ/γ|~10⁻⁶ upgrades R3 from ansatz toward derived. Added Ben
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-03 02:35 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.212
v1.0.212 — site currentVersion sync (datestamp beats stale July-2 human-format record)
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-03 02:35 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.132
v3.1.132 — site currentVersion sync (datestamp beats stale July-2 human-format record)
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 02:35 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.101
v1A.0.101 — site currentVersion sync (datestamp beats stale July-2 human-format record)
VERSIONPaper 52026-07-03 02:32 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.101
v0.1.101 — site currentVersion sync (correct bump args; datestamp 2026-07-03)
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-03 02:32 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.212
v1.0.212 — site currentVersion sync (correct bump args; datestamp 2026-07-03)
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-03 02:32 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.132
v3.1.132 — site currentVersion sync (correct bump args; datestamp 2026-07-03)
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 02:32 PT · 14 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.101
v1A.0.101 — site currentVersion sync (correct bump args; datestamp 2026-07-03)
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 01:06 PT · 15 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.101
truth-audit downgrade: removed unverified BS Eq.7.24/coefficient/power-law/10^-6 claims; kept verified BS structure (gamma^2=1 fixed point, four-fermion, |gamma|-sign); R3 closure unchanged
VERSIONP1A2026-07-03 00:57 PT · 16 hr ago P1A bumped to v1A.0.100
R3: fold real Benedetti-Speziale one-loop beta-function (JHEP 06(2011)107 Eq.7.24) into Route-3. Adds mu d(gamma^2)/dmu = -(gamma^2-1)^2 (mu^2 kappa^2/(8pi)^2)(23 gamma^2+5), the |gamma|-dependent gamma^2=1 UV fixed point, four-fermion orig
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-03 00:14 PT · 16 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.99
R3 Immirzi-running arithmetic fix: delta_gamma/gamma corrected 10^-2 -> ~0.3 (formula 32/(12pi^2)~0.27); R3 closure unaffected (>=60 orders margin); closes genuinely-new self-inconsistency (OpenAI-M2/E5 KNOWN-HONEST item)
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-02 19:34 PT · 21 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.98
RS14 evidentiary-status re-flags (Grok+Gemini), pattern-066 truth-audit: two honest sharpenings, no fabrication. (1) Sec X all-orders transparency made explicit as resting on two exact identities (algebraic Cartan T=0 + pointwise algebraic-
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-02 19:33 PT · 21 hr ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.98
RS14 calibrated-reviewer (Grok+Gemini) evidentiary-status re-flags, truth-audited pattern-066: two honest sharpenings, no fabrication, Tier-I not underclaimed. (1) Sec X all-orders transparency: added explicit reasoning that the all-orders
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-02 19:02 PT · 21 hr ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.96
Reframe-hardening pass: added ChatGPT-requested consolidated notation table (Cag/beta/theta/Omega_a/f_a/m/MPl/DeltaNeff/alpha) as a full-width table*. Dominant reviewer theme (three cross-checks over-framed as ECH theory-tests) was already
VERSIONp52026-07-02 17:53 PT · 23 hr ago P5 bumped to v0.1.101-2026-07-02
RS14 honest-framing closure (P4 approach applied to P5): softened the primary-null exclusion claim to counting-statistics-only + named the omitted systematic channels (fixed-void-geometry membership +/-0.34-0.37pp FoG MC, residual classifie
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-02 16:39 PT · 1d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.212
R-round closure: sharpened forward-model framing on the ~53% imaging+morphology l=1 fraction to preclude over-claim reading of the +3.64 sigma residual (minority/not-explained/~47%-open + central null-dipole does not depend on explaining re
VERSIONp42026-07-02 16:06 PT · 1d ago P4 bumped to v1.0.211
Close Gemini + Grok MINORS (v1.0.210 MINOR/MINOR) toward ACCEPT. KEY REAL CLOSURE (Gemini, Appendix E): replaced the qualitative 5-8% edge-on sensitivity-penalty bound with an EMPIRICAL axis-ratio metric — pulled b/a for all 3,201,160 class
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-02 14:37 PT · 1d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.210
Extended forward model: real DR8-sweep per-galaxy morphology (b/a, fracdev, shape_r) forward-modelled for all 3,201,160 spirals (100% match). Raises forward-modelled l=1 fraction 52.4%->53.0% (+0.7pt, cos +0.84); morphology adds negligibly
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-02 10:39 PT · 1d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.132
Internal-consistency fix: reconciled abstract summary block vs III/pathc_caveats(i) on DESI injection-recovery status. Abstract carried stale 'DESI injection-recovery was not executed / two Jaccard metrics' (2-gate); reconciled to true curr
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-02 02:01 PT · 1d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.97
RS8 Grok rho_Lambda-mapping circularity re-flag closed by non-circularity signpost in App B: Eq.(onshell_rho) is a conservative UPPER bound on the bounce-scale density (adopting the largest defensible source makes the ~120-OOM hierarchy HAR
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-02 01:33 PT · 1d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.131
ML-hygiene: scaler-leakage audit. DESI 5-fold J=0.862 / OOD J=0.732 confirmed leak-free (per-spectrum median normalization is row-wise/split-independent); genuine full-sample-scaler leak is tabular-only (eROSITA/NEOWISE/Gaia), already discl
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-02 00:58 PT · 1d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.209
Forward-model the +3.64σ canonical-mask ℓ=1 residual: imaging systematic (depth/PSF/EBV/leg/density) forward-models ≈54% of the residual amplitude (mask-stable, cosθ=+0.83, correct direction); remaining ~half disclosed as honest open item p
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-02 00:53 PT · 1d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.130
DESI injection-recovery folded in: closes the reviewer MAJOR that DESI (73% of catalog) was never sensitivity-tested. Real NOIRLab SPARCL DESI-DR1 re-pull (20k spectra) scored with the 5-seed production BigAE ensemble; wave14 protocol. Broa
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-02 00:50 PT · 1d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.96
Operator-basis completion: close the two previously-omitted parity-odd operators. Parity-odd four-fermion Holst partner (V.A cross term) inherits R1 M_Pl^-2 suppression + vanishing coherent mean field. Jackiw-Pi gravitational Chern-Simons R
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 16:47 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.95
Surgically removed the exploratory w0wa (overlap-uncorrected supernova) analysis per author decision: entire Appendix A (app:w0wa) with physics interpretation, caveats (a)-(e), and Table II (tab:iter2_posterior); both main-body pointer para
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 16:10 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.208
arXiv packaging: fixed a dead artifact link (canonical_mask_nside64.npy never committed) -> reverted to texttt. v1.0.208. Recompile clean, latex-audit 0 overfull, tarball standalone-compiles. READY TO SUBMIT.
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 15:00 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.207
RS10 (Gemini): removed App-B Table 5 (tab:bias_tests) T5 linear-Pearson-vs-raw-RA row entirely (Pearson invalid for circular RA coordinate, 0deg=360deg). Battery now 7 tabulated tests; directional/RA-dependent leakage tested correctly by th
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 15:00 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.94
RS10 (Grok+Gemini 2-vendor): scoped out the w0wa control-chain sigma-distance entirely. Removed provisional 2.1/2.8/3.4-sigma figures; control chains now report central values (sign of phantom-divide crossing) ONLY, with explicit statement
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-01 14:57 PT · 2d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.129
EXT RS10 Gemini REJECT (data-integrity) truth-audit: all 4 claims already-disclosed or a survey-composition misread; added explicit LAMOST-zero-in-headline/recommended exclusion sentence citing sixway_dedup_artifact.json; no science number
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 14:22 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.206
RS9 EXT closure: 8 Grok+Gemini main-text minors (inherited-power ceiling, GZ1 purity/completeness to main text, Shamir caveat echoed verbatim in Conclusions, block-bootstrap null figure, T5 Result cell filled, non-uniform CE-ResNet vs App-D
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 14:20 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.93
RS9 Grok/Gemini MINOR closure: sharpened w0wa control-chain convergence disclosure (R-1~0.05, live re-run pending, sign-consistency-only load-bearing); expunged buggy parameter_summary.json from public repo + updated data-availability to st
VERSIONPaper 52026-07-01 14:20 PT · 2d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.100-2026-07-01
RS9-EXT closure (Grok+Gemini MINOR-REVISIONS, no verdict-blocking MAJOR). Framing/signposting only (pattern-069): (1) Paper-IV independence sharpened up front in abstract; (2) primary-path pre-registration made unmistakable with a-priori gr
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 13:49 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.205
RS8 Grok+Gemini minors closed: (1) abstract/intro flag +3.64/+7.28 as diagnostics not detections; (2) GZ1-only sub-model power stated (N 9.5e5->1.5e4, ~7.9x floor); (3) peq>0.6 pre-reg moved before result; (4) compact 8-anchor battery table
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 13:11 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.92
RS7 signposting: inline pointer at headline w0wa product-likelihood introduction now states the overlap is disclosed (caveat e), the headline w0wa is not used for quantitative inference, and directional robustness is demonstrated by the two
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-01 13:10 PT · 2d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.128
EXT RS7 signposting closure: dedup-count reproducibility artifact (outputs/sixway_dedup_artifact.json, verdict EXACT-MATCH to paper claim) + held-out DESI 5-fold (J=0.862) now cited inline at the headline 275,151->269,317 count claim, killi
VERSIONPaper 22026-07-01 13:09 PT · 2d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.85
RS7-EXT-P2 single-source-dependence closure: two-vendor convergent (Grok+ChatGPT MAJOR) finding that all significances are post-hoc rescalings of a single Heinrich et al. Fisher forecast, so not independent evidence. Added explicit Single-s
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-01 13:09 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.95
RS7 ChatGPT-REJECT closure-framing sharpening: up-front boxed 'what this paper does and does not establish' + title tightened to 'channel-level amplitude closure of four enumerated routes under stated assumptions'. No fabrication; every rej
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 12:27 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.204
RS6 EXT closure: joint-systematics signpost+caveat (ChatGPT MAJOR: 9/24-template WLS marginalizes depth+morphology jointly, confidence via injection-recovery g=2a-1 floor+cut sweep; fully-simultaneous single-likelihood marginalization flagg
VERSIONPaper 22026-07-01 11:23 PT · 2d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.84
RS5-EXT-P2 signposting closure (pattern-069): all 6 ChatGPT + 3 Grok re-flagged MAJORs are already-addressed concerns (recast-not-independent-Fisher, cubic-transmission linear-only load-bearing caveat, Cai/Li symbolic-not-numerical, local-t
VERSIONPaper 52026-07-01 11:23 PT · 2d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.99-2026-07-01
EXT RS5 closure: 6 ChatGPT + 1 Grok majors truth-audited (all already substantively addressed); added Response-to-common-referee-concerns signposting box (pattern-069) mapping each recurring concern to its section. 0 undef refs, 0 overfull
VERSIONPaper 32026-07-01 11:20 PT · 2d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.127
EXT RS5 closure (ChatGPT REJECT harsh-outlier + Grok major-rev; text/framing only, no science number changed): fixed Grok M1 tier-1 injection-recovery wording inconsistency for DESI (no injection-recovery run; robustness carried by 5-fold J
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-07-01 11:19 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.94
EXT RS5 closure: ChatGPT REJECT (8 MAJOR) + Grok major-rev (3 MAJOR) truth-audited — all FALSE-POSITIVE re-flags of already-stated scope boundaries (operator-basis incompleteness, on-shell dim ansatz, R2/R3 EFT upper bounds, R4 free-couplin
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 11:19 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.203
EXT RS5 closure: ChatGPT 7-MAJOR harsh outlier (Grok+Gemini 0 MAJOR) truth-audited source-cited. 5 FALSE-POSITIVE (already handled in-text), 2 VERIFIED-CLOSED with honest caveats (no number changed): (5) WLS z~-18 block-bootstrap scope cave
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 11:18 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.91
EXT RS5 closure (ChatGPT/Grok/Gemini all major-rev). Truth-audit: nearly all majors ALREADY-ADDRESSED in v86-v90 (torsion framing scoped to stock-CAMB radiation-proxy; NaMaster foreground/beta-alpha degeneracy scope note; 12pct EB bias docu
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 10:47 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.90
Addressed ChatGPT-B2 (tautological-fit concern) with a real prior-predictive Monte-Carlo: at fixed C_agamma=8, 11.9% of prior draws reproduce beta_obs=0.342+/-0.094deg within 1sigma (24.6% within 2sigma); continuous-coupling prior 5.4%/12.0
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-07-01 09:51 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.89
CLOSED ChatGPT-B1 with real MCMC: ran the two SN-overlap control chains. Pantheon+-only w0=-0.874+/-0.059, w0+wa=-1.404+/-0.190 (quintom-B 2.1sig); DES-SN5YR-only w0=-0.787+/-0.063, w0+wa=-1.572+/-0.206 (3.4/2.8sig). Quintom-B direction sur
VERSIONPaper 42026-07-01 07:04 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.202
CLOSED ChatGPT-M2 with real compute: GZ1-only classifier (human labels ONLY, no CE-ResNet pseudo-labels; val 0.978) gives chirality dipole z=-0.04sigma (rank-p=0.45) -> null holds -> the vanishing dipole is NOT a CE-ResNet labeling artifact
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-30 18:10 PT · 2d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.83
Fresh INT: Gemini MAJOR but ESSENTIAL:None, free of critical scientific errors, suitable for PRD; Grok+OpenAI MAJOR (all structural/framing OPINION not science). Falsified extensive findings (r=0.84 in caption, title IS Sensitivity Recast,
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-30 18:10 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.88
Fresh INT: Gemini ACCEPT-w-minor (praised retitle), OpenAI MAJOR (arithmetic confirmed numbers correct), Grok REJECT (falsified). Fixed real abstract<->body inconsistency (25x fine-tuning mislabel -> matches body >=100x cos-flat); quantitat
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-30 18:03 PT · 2d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.201
Fresh INT all-MAJOR (rose from MINOR; presentation/clarity not science). Fixed OpenAI E1 (abstract Table III->Table IV ref); added A_p=2(f_CW-0.5) mapping to abstract (Gemini z-miscompute FALSIFIED, off by factor-2). Compute residuals queue
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-30 18:03 PT · 2d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.98-2026-06-30
Fresh INT all-MAJOR; sole structural residual = Paper IV in-prep. Strengthened Appendix A mitigation (headline df_CW is monopole-invariant -> rests on public CC-BY Paper-IV labels not amplitude); abstract p-range grid-resolved 0.13-0.48; ac
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-30 18:02 PT · 2d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.93
Fresh INT: Gemini ACCEPT-w-minor (praised Table III evidentiary tiers), OpenAI MAJOR, Grok REJECT (future-date FP, pattern-064). Fixed real Xi/Dinf bookkeeping drift (10^-121 -> reconciled ~4e-122, no fabrication); added Nieh-Yan convention
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 18:00 PT · 2d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.126
Closed OpenAI MAJOR (E7/M9 mixed-denominator Table I rates: real SDSS/LAMOST denominator+rate corrections, also closes Gemini M1); eROSITA axis reproducibility (membership-list + reproducible raw cut); Planck held-out p-value verified exact
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-30 17:15 PT · 2d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.97
RREXT ChatGPT MAJOR framing closed: DESIVAST void null is sole title headline (T-Web demoted to secondary cross-check, B3); unscoped superlatives removed (M6). Recompiled clean, mirrored all served paths.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 16:49 PT · 3d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.125
Scrubbed internal version-control language from the published body (revised-in-vX/superseded/R54/ext3_fm tags) — a Grok REJECT driver; verified 0 remain. Title+abstract now headline validated subset (>=268,519 + 798 exploratory). f_NL 8.98-
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 16:15 PT · 3d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.124
Fixed table* notes truncation: eROSITA/Gaia IF cross-validation reliability disclosures + recommended-tier 275,151->269,317 chain now RENDER (were silently dropped from PDF). Likely a hidden cause of P3 reviewer flags about missing tiering/
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 16:09 PT · 3d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.123
Folded P3 compute artifacts: independent 6-way dedup script (275,151->269,317 exact-match, reproducible) addresses OpenAI E1; held-out re-score (DESI Jaccard 0.862 OOS, Planck 1.60x OOS p=5.5e-4) addresses E2/E6.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-30 15:44 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.87
Framing de-overclaim to close text-addressable external MAJOR (P1A evidentiary-status Table III; P1B retitled+rescoped to consistency-check companion).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-30 15:44 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.92
Framing de-overclaim to close text-addressable external MAJOR (P1A evidentiary-status Table III; P1B retitled+rescoped to consistency-check companion).
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.96
Drive-to-ACCEPT: Paper IV self-contained methodology appendix; randoms-weighting intuition. RCEXT 1 MAJOR + 1 ACCEPT -> cap 89 (closest to gate).
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.200
Drive-to-ACCEPT: estimator decision-tree Table I; edge-on bias-exclusion; calibration clarity. RCEXT 1 MAJOR -> cap 89.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.122
Drive-to-ACCEPT: fixed Table I counts in-body; three-tier validation block up front; honest null in abstract. RCEXT 3/3 MAJOR -> cap 86.
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.82
Drive-to-ACCEPT: Scope sensitivity-recast banner to abstract sentence 1; cubic-order uncertainty elevated. RCEXT 2 MAJOR -> cap 86.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.86
Drive-to-ACCEPT: relocated w0wa overlap-uncorrected result to Appendix A; named 2 control chains as deferrals. RCEXT 1 MAJOR -> cap 89.
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-30 14:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.91
Drive-to-ACCEPT: removed companion-derived numbers from abstract/Table I; fNL exclusivity into Table I; ansatz-insensitivity. RCEXT 3/3 MAJOR -> cap 86 until reviewers accept.
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.95
INT-M2: closed version-history-prose removal; 2 rebuttals (monopole-subtracted residuals, exact-integer sigma); falsified char-map artifacts (0.05^1/6, chi2).
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.199
INT-M2: closed 2 conservative null-hardening (sigma-juxtaposition diagnostics-not-detections, A_p units); falsified abstract-qualifier + Eq-4 OCR re-flags.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.121
INT-M2: 0 new MAJORs (all re-flags); falsified dedup-sum arithmetic (375k->275k) + Cramer-V OCR; hardened footnote/abstract/Table-I disclosures.
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.81
INT-M2: closed 2 (uncorrelated qualifier, SDB units/c=1); falsified OpenAI N2-vs-N3 triangle count; N3-scaling + scope rebuttals.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.85
INT-M2: closed abstract fine-tuning quantifier (~25x); 2 rebuttals (w0wa retention, double-angle note); falsified OpenAI sign error + extraction artifact.
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-30 12:16 PT · 3d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.90
INT-M2: 0 new real findings (all re-flags/Grok-064/extraction artifacts); added mass-dimension accounting + T=0-is-consequence rebuttal-hardening.
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
RC-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
RC-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
RC-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
RC-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago PAPER-5 bumped to 0.1.94-2026-06-29
Round C INT closures (FINAL round)
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago PAPER-4 bumped to 1.0.198
Round C INT closures (FINAL round)
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago PAPER-1B bumped to 1B.0.84
Round C INT closures (FINAL round)
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-29 12:06 PT · 4d ago PAPER-1A bumped to 1A.0.89
Round C INT closures (FINAL round)
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
RB-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
RB-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
RB-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago PAPER-5 bumped to 0.1.93-2026-06-29
Round B INT closures
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago PAPER-4 bumped to 1.0.197
Round B INT closures
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-29 11:35 PT · 4d ago PAPER-2 bumped to 1.7.80
Round B INT closures
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
RA-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
RA-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
RA-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
RA-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
RA-INT · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.92-2026-06-29
Round A INT closures
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.196
Round A INT closures
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.79
Round A INT closures
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.83
Round A INT closures
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-29 10:17 PT · 4d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.88
Round A INT closures
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-28 07:59 PT · 5d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.195
De-stale artifact links: /blob/53b41d12/ (25 commits stale) -> /blob/main/; immutable tag deferred to submission
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-28 06:33 PT · 5d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.91
Companion self-containment: Paper IV inputs table + monopole-invariance reinforced
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-28 06:33 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.82
Companion self-containment: imported-theory-results summary
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-28 06:04 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.87
Self-contained companion-imported-inputs table (3-reviewer standalone-readability MAJOR)
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-28 05:41 PT · 5d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.78
INT-X real fixes: 5->5.5sigma consistency, dedicated joint-Fisher subsection, heuristic qualifier
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-28 05:41 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.86
INT-X real fixes: fig legend, sigma-comparability, baryon phrasing, dgamma derivation
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-28 05:15 PT · 5d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.194
Close 4 real INT-cross-check items: WLS provenance, sigma-comparability, mask-threshold, filename density
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-28 04:41 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.81
Complete w0wa sigma-removal: drop Table II vs-LCDM column; INT cross-check
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-28 04:10 PT · 5d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.90
Explicit MDE label on void-bin null; INT cross-check 2/3 ACCEPT
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-28 03:36 PT · 5d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.120
Honest abstract reframe: lead with validated >=268,519; de-headline 141x/73x (5-reviewer convergence)
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.89-2026-06-28
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.193
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.119
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.77
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.80
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-28 03:23 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.85
EXTDB2-close real-fix wave
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
EXTDB-close · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.88-2026-06-27
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.192
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.118
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.76
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.79
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-27 23:58 PT · 5d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.84
EXTDB closure: prominent disclosures + in-paper rebuttals
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-27 01:49 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
EXTDB · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-27 01:49 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
EXTDB · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-27 01:49 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
EXTDB · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
FINDING ✓Paper 32026-06-27 01:38 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXTDB-P3-catgrade closed (real-action)
MINOR: 'catalog-grade' 269,317 sums in Gaia+eROSITA which FAILED injection-recovery (self-favoring label)
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-27 01:38 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
EXTDB · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-27 01:38 PT · 6d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.117
De-biased EXT closure: 'catalog-grade' relabeled to exclude FAIL surveys (Gaia/eROSITA)
FINDING ✓Paper 1A2026-06-27 01:15 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXTDB-P1A-overclaim closed (real-action)
MINOR: '13 logically-independent barriers' overclaims independence (several share ansatz/are heuristic)
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-27 01:15 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
EXTDB · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-27 01:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.83
De-biased EXT closure: '13 logically-independent'->'mechanism-class' self-favoring fix
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-26 23:59 PT · 6d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.87-2026-06-26
R57 hardened closures (f_NL cite-P2, self-favoring fixes); recompiled+re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-26 23:59 PT · 6d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.191
R57 hardened closures (f_NL cite-P2, self-favoring fixes); recompiled+re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-26 23:59 PT · 6d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.75
R57 hardened closures (f_NL cite-P2, self-favoring fixes); recompiled+re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-26 23:59 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.82
R57 hardened closures (f_NL cite-P2, self-favoring fixes); recompiled+re-mirrored
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R57-paper-5-abstract closed (real-action)
MINOR: internal monopole 0.26->0.28pp (self-favoring understatement)
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R57-paper-5-abstract closed (real-action)
MINOR: Paper IV dipole +0.43->+0.41sigma
FINDING ✓Paper 42026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-4 R57-paper-4-sec:pari closed (real-action)
MINOR: Shamir 'excluded'->'in tension' (self-favoring overstatement)
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R57-paper-2-TblIV closed (real-action)
MINOR: sigma_eff mis-citation
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R57-paper-2-SecVI->I closed (real-action)
MINOR: DBI cross-ref retarget
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R57-paper-2-SecIV/VI closed (real-action)
MINOR: b_phi marginalize/fixes wording inconsistency
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R57 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
FINDING ✓Paper 1A2026-06-26 22:07 PT · 6d ago paper-1a R56-P1A-4-OPEN closed (real-action)
MINOR: Footnote attributes '2.6-5sigma realistic' to sigma(fnl)~1.0 regime but |fnl|/sigma=4.375/1.0=4.4sigma does not span 2.6-5sigma. Favorable upper end (5sigma) traces to sigma~0.7 ideal; 2.6sigma lower …
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R56-P5-Gem-M1 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Self-favoring: 'within order-unity of observation' downplays a -1.38sigma cluster residual (filament sigma=-4.66 vs pred=-3.28).
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R56-P5-E8 closed (real-action)
MINOR: '100% covariate-complete' vs edge-on on 152,455 subset: real ambiguity about which covariates are complete for which subset.
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R56-P5-E2 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Redshift p=0.372 vs 0.80/0.81: two distinct statistics (max-abs-dev vs quintile LEE) presented without distinction, creating apparent contradiction.
FINDING ✓Paper 52026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-5 R56-P5-E1 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Paper IV dipole +0.41sigma(p=0.31)/+0.43sigma(p=0.30): 0.41sigma->p=0.31 inconsistent on any tail convention; two quotes also disagree with each other.
FINDING ✓Paper 32026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-3 R56-P3-F2 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Two sites label eROSITA selection 'canonical-S top-298' contradicting the paper's own finding that there is no reproducible canonical-S axis for eROSITA (caption L703: 0.259 axis distinct from canonic…
FINDING ✓Paper 32026-06-26 20:04 PT · 6d ago paper-3 R56-P3-F1 closed (real-action)
MAJOR: MAJOR load-bearing rendering bug: the 6-note flushleft footnote block was inside the table* float, overflowing ~676pt. Silently clipped off page 7 — all 6 honest-reporting disclosures (Gaia DR3 reliab…
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R56-P2-4 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Squeezed-mode index inconsistency: Eq(2)/Tbl I/Fig1 define soft=k1, but L773 uses x3=k3/k1 where k3<<k1, so soft=k3, contradicting the k1-soft ordering.
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R56-P2-3 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Row label 'Corrected (10% residual)' contradicts the row showing zero-residual Ideal values — self-contradictory.
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R56-P2-2 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Self-favoring: epsilon-correction stated as 'lesssim 0.4sigma' but 8% -> Delta_f=0.35 -> 0.35*0.84/0.7=0.42sigma, which exceeds 0.4.
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-2 R56-P2-1 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Abstract endpoint order inconsistency: 'CMB Fisher to LSS' maps to 5.5->5.2 but text says '5.2-5.5'. Real directional inconsistency.
FINDING ✓Paper 1A2026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-1a R56-P1A-3 closed (real-action)
MINOR: delta_NY is added to alpha/M which has dim [mass]^{-1}; additive consistency forces [delta_NY]=-1. Missing dimensional note on finite Nieh-Yan piece.
FINDING ✓Paper 1A2026-06-26 20:03 PT · 6d ago paper-1a R56-P1A-2 closed (real-action)
MINOR: Abstract cross-ref \ref{sec:loophole} wrong — missing-operator acknowledgments live in §fourroute_summary (L2011-2019), not §loophole (L2592+).
FINDING ✓Paper 1A2026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago paper-1a R56-P1A-1 closed (real-action)
MINOR: 'residual 10^5 tracks the exponential e^{-3N_tot}' — number 10^5 cannot track e^{-3N}~10^{-120}; it tracks the inverse-dilution e^{+3*Delta_N} at Delta_N~4.
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 20:02 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R56 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-26 20:01 PT · 6d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.86-2026-06-26
R56 hardened de-biased re-review closures
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-26 20:01 PT · 6d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.116
R56 hardened de-biased re-review closures
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-26 20:01 PT · 6d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.74
R56 hardened de-biased re-review closures
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-26 20:01 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.81
R56 hardened de-biased re-review closures
FINDING (verified)Paper 52026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-5 EXT21-P5-04 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: Gemini #2: Expand DR2/Rubin selection-effect untangling section; current treatment insufficient for DR2-era data.
FINDING (verified)Paper 52026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-5 EXT21-P5-03 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: All three EXT reviewers: Archival DOI should be inserted; current text is a placeholder.
FINDING (verified)Paper 52026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-5 EXT21-P5-02 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT M1 + Gemini: Abstract too dense; competing statistics make the primary result hard to identify on first read.
FINDING (verified)Paper 52026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-5 EXT21-P5-01 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: ChatGPT M2 + Grok #1: DESIVAST should be explicitly boxed as primary result, T-Web as secondary cross-check; current framing risks misreading primary/secondary hierarchy.
FINDING (verified)Paper 42026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-4 EXT21-P4-04 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: Gemini G4: Fragment '…would be' and draft markers near pg 1→2 appear to be incomplete sentence / editorial artifact.
FINDING (verified)Paper 42026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-4 EXT21-P4-03 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT C2 + Gemini: Data Availability uses future tense for archival DOI; no DOI has been minted yet.
FINDING (verified)Paper 42026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-4 EXT21-P4-02 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT C1: Fig 7 raw Catalog-A panel appears sparser than equivariant panel — visual inconsistency that could invite misreading (reviewer notes: 'does not affect the null result').
FINDING (verified)Paper 42026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-4 EXT21-P4-01 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: ChatGPT C5: Shamir 'excluded by a factor' statement needs a matched-footprint/matched-analysis caveat since Shamir used a different pipeline.
FINDING (verified)Paper 32026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXT21-P3-05 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: All three EXT reviewers: eROSITA membership-only reproducibility limitation should be prominently disclosed; non-members cannot reproduce the score axis.
FINDING (verified)Paper 32026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXT21-P3-04 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT + Grok: Add catalog-tier-summary table to appendix listing survey, count, gate status, validity tier.
FINDING (verified)Paper 32026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXT21-P3-03 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: ChatGPT + Grok: f_NL values 8.98 vs 16.85 are juxtaposed without a clear 'not directly comparable' qualifier.
FINDING (verified)Paper 32026-06-26 19:43 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXT21-P3-02 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT: Cramér's V display omits the square-root symbol — V should be √(χ²/(N(k−1))).
FINDING (verified)Paper 32026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-3 EXT21-P3-01 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: All three EXT reviewers: DESI 195,829 science-target count should be shown side-by-side with the 73× catalog total for clarity.
FINDING (verified)Paper 22026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-2 EXT21-P2-05 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: All three EXT reviewers: Zenodo DOI should be inserted before publication; current placeholder is incomplete.
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-2 EXT21-P2-04 closed (real-action)
NIT: ChatGPT M6: Table V column header 'Convention' is misleading — the Li row is a single-time-ordering stress test, not an alternative convention.
FINDING (verified)Paper 22026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-2 EXT21-P2-03 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: Grok m1/m2: Front-load 'recast not independent forecast' statement; additive-quadrature caveat should appear earlier.
FINDING (verified)Paper 22026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-2 EXT21-P2-02 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: ChatGPT M4: b_φ 'Heinrich marginalize' vs UMF-fixed contradiction — claimed Heinrich marginalizes b_φ when the paper uses UMF universality to fix it.
FINDING ✓Paper 22026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-2 EXT21-P2-01 closed (real-action)
MINOR: ChatGPT M1: Sec VI.C CDF-tail explanatory note is mathematically misleading — states 'Φ≈0.006, contributing ≈18% correction from each tail' but the upper tail is negligible (~10⁻⁴⁰) and only the lower…
FINDING (verified)Paper 1B2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1b EXT21-P1B-04 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT m9 + Grok min3: Move burn-in detail to appendix; current placement in main text interrupts flow.
FINDING ✓Paper 1B2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1b EXT21-P1B-03 closed (real-action)
MINOR: ChatGPT m6: 'Table classifies every quantitative claim' is literally false — Table V is a 10-row selection omitting several key posteriors.
FINDING ✓Paper 1B2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1b EXT21-P1B-02 closed (real-action)
MINOR: ChatGPT m2: 'across the spectator-consistent posterior' mislabels the full scan-prior box span [0.01,0.48]° — contradicts the paper's own Ωa<0.01 spectator-safe criterion.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1B2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1b EXT21-P1B-01 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: All three EXT reviewers: w0wa σ-distances in Table II need explicit 'diagnostic only' caveat; not suitable for model selection.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1A2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXT21-P1A-05 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: ChatGPT MINOR: Fig 1 ekpyrotic-row labels crowded; Fig 5 panel title 'RG Running of α/M' too definitive given ansatz status.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1A2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXT21-P1A-04 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
NIT: Gemini: Two typos — 'programme mme' duplicate on p2 and 'Eq. (1is not' missing closing paren on p6 fn1.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1A2026-06-26 19:42 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXT21-P1A-03 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: Grok MAJOR: Expand Sec X.D with explicit leading-order perturbed Holst term; identified as a conceptual gap.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1A2026-06-26 19:41 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXT21-P1A-02 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: Grok MAJOR: title/abstract 'closure' overclaims an operator-level theorem; proposed rename to remove 'closure' language.
FINDING (verified)Paper 1A2026-06-26 19:41 PT · 6d ago paper-1a EXT21-P1A-01 closed (truth-audit-falsification)
MINOR: Paper not self-contained; load-bearing numbers live in in-prep companion papers (F_NL, ALP birefringence β). All three EXT reviewers converged on this as the headline concern.
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 19:38 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5 (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 19:37 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4 (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 19:37 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3 (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 19:37 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2 (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 19:37 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 19:37 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a (houston-external)
EXT21 · reviewers: ChatGPT Pro, Grok, Gemini
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-26 18:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.85-2026-06-26
integrity-audit honest-reporting fixes
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-26 18:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.190
integrity-audit honest-reporting fixes
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-26 18:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.115
integrity-audit honest-reporting fixes
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-26 18:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.73
integrity-audit honest-reporting fixes
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-26 18:15 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.78
integrity-audit honest-reporting fixes
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.84-2026-06-26
R53-R55 closure wave: real items closed incl P3 Table IX fabrication recompute; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.189
R53-R55 closure wave: real items closed incl P3 Table IX fabrication recompute; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.114
R54 MAJOR closure: Table IX NANOGrav BF prior-robustness 3 non-fiducial rows recomputed from committed chain; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.72
R53-R55 closure wave: R55 Sec III.A mechanism phrasing corrected; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.77
R53-R55 closure wave: real items closed incl P3 Table IX fabrication recompute; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-26 17:58 PT · 6d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.80
R53-R55 closure wave: real items closed incl P3 Table IX fabrication recompute; version+date bumped; PDF re-mirrored
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 17:34 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 17:34 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 17:33 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 17:33 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 17:33 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 17:33 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R55 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 17:14 PT · 6d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R54 · reviewers: OpenAI gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R53 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 42026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-4
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1A2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1a
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 52026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-5
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 32026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-3
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 22026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-2
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
REVIEW ROUNDPaper 1B2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago R-round dispatched on paper-1b
R52 · reviewers: OpenAI o3/gpt-5, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4.3, Claude Opus
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.188
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.79
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.76
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.83
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.71
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-26 15:29 PT · 7d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.113
R52+R53 INT+EXT closure wave: real MINOR/arithmetic items closed, recompiled 0 undef-refs, 0 BLOCKER/0 genuine MAJOR — converged; awaiting D/P-round + Houston sign-off
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-20 12:23 PT · 13d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.76
v1B.0.76 (2026-06-20 — P-round: 3 reproducibility datasets published public on HF (bamfai/p1b-*); Appendix A URLs corrected Hubify→bamfai; P1B now fully reproducible. No science change.)
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-19 15:36 PT · 14d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.83
D1 visual polish: [A1]-[A30] artifact IDs, Fig 8 two-panel colorbars, Fig 2 pie to bar, Fig 5+9 panel labels, Table VII dagger; readiness 96
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-19 15:36 PT · 14d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.113
D1 visual polish: fig_gallery full-width + caption dagger; readiness 96
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-19 15:36 PT · 14d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.71
D1 visual polish: full-width Fisher figure + caption overflow fixes; readiness 96
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-19 15:36 PT · 14d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.75
D1 visual polish: table layout + figure caption panel labels; readiness 96
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-19 15:35 PT · 14d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.79
D1 visual polish: Table II full-width, TikZ 14-barrier schematic, Eq line breaks; readiness 96
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-18 19:28 PT · 14d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.82
R40+EXT20 final round: R40 2 label fixes + EXT20 χ² rounding fix. UNANIMOUS ACCEPT. Readiness 99.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-18 19:28 PT · 14d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.112
R40+EXT20 final round: R40 repro-path fix. EXT20 UNANIMOUS ACCEPT. Readiness 99.
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-18 19:28 PT · 14d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.70
R40+EXT20 final round: EXT20 micro-fix Table IV 0.1σ→0.4σ. EXT20 UNANIMOUS ACCEPT. Readiness 99.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-18 19:28 PT · 14d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.74
R40+EXT20 final round: UNCHANGED from v1B.0.74 — R40+EXT20 ACCEPT; EXT19 ALP-relic fixes re-verified correct. Readiness 98→99 earned this round.
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-18 19:28 PT · 14d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.78
R40+EXT20 final round: 2 prose artifacts stripped (cosmetic/labeling only). EXT20 UNANIMOUS ACCEPT. Readiness 99.
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.80-2026-06-13
EXT16-closure: math V\mbox{-}Web at l.2864 corrected to T\mbox{-}Web (pattern-060: \mbox{} math subscript escape missed by pattern-059 grep); nomenclature note direction corrected; duplicate T-Web phrase removed.
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.188
P4 FROZEN at v1.0.188 — universal 3/3 ACCEPT (EXT12+EXT14+EXT16 confirmed; 4 consecutive rounds). No changes.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.111
EXT16-closure: Table IX tablenote(a) clarified — non-fiducial γ rows use row-specific prior density 1/Δγ denominator with explicit reweighting note; computation chain per-row now explicit.
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.68
EXT16-closure: Sec VI.C CDF-tail direction corrected from 'reduces' to 'raises' — for narrow delta-prior B, the CDF-tail from 5.69 to 7.0 is upward (raises evidence). Sign typo fixed.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.72
P1B FROZEN at v1B.0.72 — universal 3/3 ACCEPT confirmed EXT14+EXT16 (ChatGPT+Grok+Gemini, 3 consecutive rounds). No changes.
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 20:51 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.77
EXT16-closure: Sec XII.A 'C/P-violating thermal scattering' propagation chain now explicit — chirality-flipping and depolarizing thermal interactions named (missed step from EXT15 Sec II.C.1 fix). No new analysis.
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.79-2026-06-13
EXT15-closure: pattern-059 math-mode subscript sweep performed — ZERO actual math-mode V-Web residuals found (pattern-057 at EXT13 had already cleared all body+math sites; EXT14 reviewer flag was a pattern-052 vindication false-positive). V
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.188
P4 FROZEN at v1.0.188 — universal 3/3 ACCEPT (first-ever ChatGPT ACCEPT in campaign confirmed EXT12+EXT14). No changes since prior review. Courtesy re-confirmation submitted EXT15.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.110
EXT15-closure: Table IX Savage-Dickey footnote enhanced with explicit Gaussian KDE values at γ*=3.0 (post density 0.461 → B_MB/free=3.23) and γ*=4.33 (post density 6.46e-5 → B_SMBHB/free=4.52e-4); ratio B_MB/SMBHB=7.14e3 derived. Genuine SD
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.67
EXT15-closure: BF self-check Eq.9 vs Eq.10 mapping corrected (Eq.9 exact CDF for narrow delta-prior B≈7.0; Eq.10 large-W approximation only valid for broad [-15,+15] delta as cross-check; Gaussian-bounce-prior uses Eq.9 exclusively). 0.18%
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.72
P1B FROZEN at v1B.0.72 — universal 3/3 ACCEPT confirmed EXT14 (ChatGPT+Grok+Gemini). No changes since EXT13-closure. Courtesy re-confirmation submitted EXT15.
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 20:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.76
EXT15-closure: 3 ChatGPT MINOR items closed — chirality-flipping clarification + dimensionless parity-odd amplitude budget + local-operator-promotion route framing; plus 3 Gemini polish items (citations clarified, γ_SU(2)≈0.274 scheme range
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.78-2026-06-13
EXT13-closure: pattern-057 V-Web body residuals closed (4 sites: lines 429, 807, 2094, 3589); Verdict.→Result. journal-style sub-header; Fig 8 confirmed clean.
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.188
P4 FROZEN at v1.0.188 — universal 3/3 ACCEPT confirmed EXT12 (first ChatGPT ACCEPT in campaign). No changes.
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.109
EXT13-closure: Abstract DESI gate type explicit (5-fold cross-validation Jaccard + native-retrain OOD Jaccard, NOT injection-recovery); Table IX BF columns carry explicit Savage-Dickey density-ratio tablenote (8 sites).
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.66
EXT13-closure: BF self-check paragraph rewritten — 3 sentences explicitly disentangle Eq.(bf_approx) delta-prior vs Eq.(bf_exact) bounce-prior; delta vs Gaussian rows differ in both prior spec AND required equation.
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.72
EXT13-closure: Release-pairing description harmonized across Sec III + Sec V.B + Conclusion (consistent c15.input.yaml likelihood names; 0.04σ ΔNeff agreement as empirical pairing-bias bound).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 19:01 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.75
EXT13-closure: Sec IV/App B dimensional bookkeeping made consistent via N_tot sentence; reheating residual clarified (local-operator-promotion reading distinguished).
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.77-2026-06-13
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.188
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.108
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.65
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.71
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 18:37 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.74
EXT11-closure: 12 ESS findings closed. EXT11=12/12 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.76-2026-06-13
EXT10-closure: V-Web to T-Web rename (235+ insertions / 181 deletions; Hahn 2007 is tidal-tensor T-Web); 7 protected V-Web (Hoffman 2012 historical); sample-count 783,820 confirmed; frozen-analysis-tree note. EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs)
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.187
EXT10-closure: Shamir [2] bibchimera FIXED (arXiv:2208.00893); 6 wording fixes (HC primary rationale; z-18 NSIDE caveat; l=2 cross-spectrum softening). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.107
EXT10-closure: top-1% to S>5 (0.87% of 22.5M-spectrum scan); catalog-grade reinforced in abstract; NANOGrav BF prior-sensitivity table (all decisive). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.64
EXT10-closure: 9 wording fixes (CGT M1/M2/M3/M9 stress-test branches; UV-independence; denominator definition; contamination scale; channel hierarchy; UMF universality). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.70
EXT10-closure: 6 wording fixes (pairing-swap test note; 40.5 H0 posterior; phantom-crossing caveats; UV-completion-independent; release-pairing). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 17:27 PT · 19d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.73
EXT10-closure: Sec IV→App B explicit ref; Route 2 sharpener; WKB 10⁻³⁵ eV inlined (companion ESS resolution). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 52026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.76-2026-06-13
EXT10-closure: V-Web to T-Web rename (235+ insertions / 181 deletions; Hahn 2007 is tidal-tensor T-Web); 7 protected V-Web (Hoffman 2012 historical); sample-count 783,820 confirmed; frozen-analysis-tree note. EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs)
VERSIONPaper 42026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.187
EXT10-closure: Shamir [2] bibchimera FIXED (arXiv:2208.00893); 6 wording fixes (HC primary rationale; z-18 NSIDE caveat; l=2 cross-spectrum softening). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 32026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.107
EXT10-closure: top-1% to S>5 (0.87% of 22.5M-spectrum scan); catalog-grade reinforced in abstract; NANOGrav BF prior-sensitivity table (all decisive). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 22026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.64
EXT10-closure: 9 wording fixes (CGT M1/M2/M3/M9 stress-test branches; UV-independence; denominator definition; contamination scale; channel hierarchy; UMF universality). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1B2026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.70
EXT10-closure: 6 wording fixes (pairing-swap test note; 40.5 H0 posterior; phantom-crossing caveats; UV-completion-independent; release-pairing). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
VERSIONPaper 1A2026-06-13 16:05 PT · 20d ago PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.73
EXT10-closure: Sec IV→App B explicit ref; Route 2 sharpener; WKB 10⁻³⁵ eV inlined (companion ESS resolution). EXT10=18/18 MINOR (zero MAJORs).
Showing up to 300 events. Older history in git log (github.com/Hubify-Projects/bigbounce) and SSOT/queue.md.