PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r17
Close exact-final viewer binding, denominator, deduplication specification, and checkpoint digest findings without changing catalog membership.
Live Research Activity
Activity Feed● LIVE
Every research event from the live database: version bumps, review rounds, finding closures, caveat resolutions, compute runs. Time-sorted descending. See /docs for how the pipeline writes here.
Looking for the progress story? The curated review-loop timeline — paper/kind filters, verdict trajectories, gap-closure and skills-growth charts — lives at /reviews. This page is the raw machine-event stream.
Versions
784
Review Rounds
75
Findings (open)
0
Findings (closed)
115
Caveats (open)
0
Caveats (closed)
10
Compute (running)
0
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r17
Close exact-final viewer binding, denominator, deduplication specification, and checkpoint digest findings without changing catalog membership.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r17
Bind viewer captures and correct checkpoint, dedup, and exclusion accounting
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r17
Bind viewer captures and correct checkpoint, dedup, and exclusion accounting
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.274
Expand Expected Calibration Error (ECE) at first use; no scientific claim, number, or caveat changed.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r16
Adopt evidence-bounded r16 control and viewer closure
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r16
Withdraw unsupported annular-deficit mechanism; add core-conditioned audit; restore exact r2 Parquet; narrow viewer-capture evidence.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r16
Close exact-final Gemini descriptive-wording finding
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.147-2026-08-03
AJ AASTeX 7.0.2 line-numbered journal-shell migration and layout closure; no science change
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.273
AASTeX 7.0.2 package and table-caption artifact-link overflow closure; no science change
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r15
AASTeX 7.0.2 line-numbered portal package, short title, verified ORCID, and evidence-bounded AI-use disclosure; no science change
paper-3 R57-paper-3-latitude closed (artifact-verification)
MINOR: 'rate' wording imprecise (non-material)
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.16
JORS submission-gate closure: the previously undispositioned 2026-07-23 Grok [MAJOR] is closed. Its literal irreconcilable-contradiction claim is FALSIFIED (pyproject.toml, codemeta.json, CITATION.cff, __init__.py and Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.146-2026-07-24
Target-program leakage prominence: abstract caveat clause, new Limitations bullet, and Conclusions conditionality sentence closing the remedy half of the 2026-07-23 Gemini [MAJOR] on Sec VI.E.d. Prose only; zero reported numbers changed.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.272
Gate 1: relocated raw SHA-256 digests, immutable revisions, and bare artifact filenames out of the primary narrative into a new artifact provenance register (Table tab:artifact_provenance, A1-A12) + Data Availability, closing the twice-dism
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.145-2026-07-24
Estimator-hierarchy sensitivity consolidation: new tab:hierarchy_sensitivity in sec:primary_path placing the focal released-parent estimate beside the two demoted any-hole estimates; all values transcribed from existing tables/artifacts, no
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.130
PRD submission-gate closure: AI Usage Disclosure section added (APS requires disclosure of substantive AI use in the submitted paper, with tool name/version, how it assisted, and how the author directed and verified it); deposit self-refere
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r14
ApJS abstract cut 426->249 words (AAS 250-word cap); deposit self-reference made drift-proof via computed patch delta (pattern-047)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.130
PRD submission-gate closure: AI Usage Disclosure section added (APS requires disclosure of substantive AI use in the submitted paper, with tool name/version, how it assisted, and how the author directed and verified it); deposit self-refere
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.127
CQG submission-gate closure: Note-scoped acknowledgments carrying IOP-mandatory competing-interests, funding, and generative-AI declarations now compile (previously trapped inside the comment block); Data and Code Availability promoted to i
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.144-2026-07-24
v0.1.144 — companion-status back-patch: the rendered Paper II bibliography reference now cites the published Zenodo record (version DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21461881, concept 10.5281/zenodo.21461880, deposited 2026-07-20, CC-BY-4.0) with its exac
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.129
v1.7.129 — companion-status back-patch: the rendered Paper I A bibliography reference now cites the published Zenodo record (version DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21481838, concept 10.5281/zenodo.21481837, deposited 2026-07-22, CC-BY-4.0) with its exa
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.271
re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r13
re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.128
re-sweep closure: Data-Availability self-reference macro-bound (drift-proof) + truthful deposit tense
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.270
confirmation-board closures: Table 5 excluded-rows label, epoch-5-breakout/epoch-47-best wording, abstract parity-bound hardening
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r12
confirmation-board closures: Zenodo tense truthful convention, shifted-annulus deficit stated honestly with in-paper mechanism, version-tag key completed
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r12
confirmation-board closures: Zenodo tense truthful convention, shifted-annulus deficit stated honestly with in-paper mechanism, version-tag key completed
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.127
confirmation-board transparency closures: prior labeled illustrative benchmark, r_eff clause, 0.36sigma, 34.7% baseline aligned, 2.63sigma recompute wording
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.142-2026-07-22
confirmation-board closures: Paper-II bibitem cited in Sec I (back-patch anchor retained), monopole significance harmonized to 9.5sigma
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.126
confirmation-board closures: archival DOI in active availability section; Fierz attribution both-named; NJL torsion operator cross-note
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.14
confirmation-board closures: Overview stub removed, null-injection realization count anchored, stale blocker sentence dropped
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.13
DOI embed: manuscript archival deposit 10.5281/zenodo.21481842 cited in Archive paragraph alongside software DOI (Houston publish-go 2026-07-21)
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.125
DOI embed: published archival deposit 10.5281/zenodo.21481838 cited in availability paragraph (Houston publish-go 2026-07-21)
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.12
Archive closure: namaster-proof 0.1.7 bound to published Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21481753; persistent-identifier submission blocker closed
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.269
Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461899 version / 21461898 concept) at abstract + Data Availability + release itemize; submission-time placeholder replaced; systematics-metadata sidecar gate honestly kept open. DOI gate CLOSED
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r11
Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461888 version / 21461887 concept) in Data Availability with the honest self-deposited-vs-AAS-journal-DOI distinction; the AAS digital-asset DOI stays an open journal gate. Archival DOI gate CL
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.126
Zenodo archival DOI embedded (10.5281/zenodo.21461881 version / 21461880 concept); Data-and-Code-Availability deferral replaced with the published deposit description; honest archived-bytes distinction stated. DOI gate CLOSED.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.268
CE-composition adjudication + honest negative integrated: Jia catalog re-provisioned (Zenodo DOI, sha-verified); GZ1 6,637 + CE-spiral 17,153 reproduced exactly, reproducible non-spiral = 819 — conflict isolated to the seeded subsample cros
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.267
Phase-2 pod-campaign integration: 4x4 joint covariance (MASTER-decoupled Cl1 z=-0.61, proxy validation rho=+0.943, BLAS caveat) closes the pod-bound refinement; G4 monopole mechanism over 16.9M banked forward passes — classifier confusion e
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.125
Dressed-metric transmission closure integrated: the bounded bounce is transparent to the conserved mode in the dressed-metric scheme (T_c(k)=1; |delta f_NL| <= 6.8e-8 at k*eta_B=1e-2 — more than four orders below the prior OOM reference), w
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.266
G1+G2 real-compute closures integrated: manifest-retained retrain (val_acc 0.9931, every ID/split/seed retained, 3-location backed up) and training-disjoint validation (acc 0.9867, kappa 0.9733 on 3000 doubly-disjoint GZ1 spirals) added wit
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.124
Three truth-audited framing/citation closures on the Eq-5 torsion paragraph: reframed from 'bound/quantified' to an explicit order-of-magnitude parametric estimate with the energy-density transfer proxy stated as asserted (not derived in-in
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.123
Model-specific torsion bound computed and integrated: Eq 5 bounds |delta f_NL^tor| via the P1A-anchored Einstein-Cartan four-fermion contact term (prefactor saturation 0.022-0.21 within EFT validity; <<1e-3 for sub-Planckian abundance; n_ps
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.265
Coverage-calibrated observed-label 95% upper limit computed and integrated: A_95^obs ~ 0.98% via 2000 random-axis injections/amplitude through the exact committed primary estimator and 10^4-draw fixed-occupancy null (headline reproduced exa
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.264
G3 joint estimator covariance integrated: new Sec 4.5 + Table 9 present the N=2000 block-bootstrap 3x3 dipole/WLS/monopole covariance (monopole z=-6.57 the only |z|>3 mode, correlations -0.037/-0.093 with the dipole estimators); six caveat
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.11
Two one-sentence closures from the exact v2B.0.10 board truth audit: explicit pytest invocation command in Sec 7 QC; explicit non-affiliation sentence (independent downstream verification layer, not an official NaMaster release) in Sec 11.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r10
Integrity reframe of the CONFIRMED circularity finding: the sub-0.1-arcsec core (170 matches) is restated everywhere (abstract, Sec 3.5, Fig 1 caption, Sec 7, Sec 8) as expected seed self-recovery — an end-to-end recovery verification, not
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.10
Optional polish closures from the v2B.0.9 truth audit: workspace-tensor regenerability surfaced in Sec 7 with a new examples/rebuild_workspace_check.py recheck script (skip-safe without PyMaster), real committed execution-cost figures (701.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.9
Claude-leg truth-audit closures: package 0.1.7 adds skipif guards to the 2 monorepo-coupled replay tests (41 pass in monorepo, 39+2-skip standalone, verified both ways), codemeta.json added, JORS availability template completed (system requ
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.124
Claude-leg truth-audit editorial closures: torsion-vanishing lemma now shows the 4D contraction coefficients (derived from the manuscript's own identities and hand-verified), Sec III.B relabeled mean-field NJL diagnostic with claim-scope so
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r9
Bounded editorial closures from the Claude-leg truth audit: machinery-as-primary-deliverable sentences in abstract + Sec 1, version-tag lineage footnote, tab:examples full-precision note for the two -0.000 redshifts, BigAE-stream copy edit.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.141-2026-07-16
Forward-leakage injection closure: new semi-analytic forward model [A47]/[A48] predicts each large raw deviation from committed per-program/imaging-leg leakage components through the measured env-by-program contingency — reproducing 77-88%
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.263
Closes the single genuinely-new-real item from the exact v1.0.262 board truth audit: the Appendix-B quarantine stability value (z=+0.48 excluded vs +0.52 baseline, c11b 10^4-perm) is now surfaced in the main-Results post-hoc-disclosure para
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.262
Closes both genuinely-new-real v1.0.261 truth-audit findings: (Ge2) plain-English raw_flip_qc_unsafe gloss at first main-text declaration; (C4) delivered per-region CW-fraction monopole correction map with binomial uncertainty (NSIDE=8 and
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.140-2026-07-16
Whole-tree global-multiplicity closure: adds family-wise-corrected significance for the most extreme deviation across the entire declared analysis tree (N=23 paths, p_min=0.0357 bright-vs-dark filament sign-flip, Bonferroni p_global<=0.822,
R-round dispatched on paper-5 (direct)
ROUND_2026-07-16-P5-v0.1.139-EXACTPDF-948e0412-CLAUDESTACK-CONFIRM · reviewers: grok-4.3 (xAI direct API): MINOR REVISIONS, gemini-3.1-pro-preview (Google direct API): MINOR REVISIONS, claude-opus subagent (Anthropic subscription): MAJOR REVISIONS, codex: ABSENT (paused, directive N)
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.261
Immutable provider overlay published: strict-primary overlay public at HF revision 911316f31c21f2c4b933a2f3a761274cfe85c6d6 (apjs-release/v1.0.259-strict-primary), all 7 files remote-byte-verified; data-availability/manifest/conclusions tex
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.8
Enforce recursive JSON-type-strict metadata validation and exact finite decouple-cell output shapes; package 0.1.6 with 41 tests.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.7
Reject non-integral public multipole inputs without coercion; add seven boundary regressions; package 0.1.5.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.7
Reject non-integral public multipole inputs without coercion; add seven boundary regressions; package 0.1.5.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.6
Close v2B.0.5 confirmation regression: restore sharded-validation section placement, correct beta_rad API example, and add archived-monorepo package isolation instructions; readiness remains 56.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.5
Close exact-board JSON strictness, CI trigger, mask-coordinate, CRediT, and dependency-disclosure findings; readiness remains 56 pending archive, confirmation, and human review.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.4
Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.4
Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.4
Close truth-audited concurrent publisher metadata/byte cross-binding; derive receipts from immutable serialized snapshots and add interleaving regression.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.3
Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.3
Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.3
Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.3
Close truth-audited concurrent receipt-validation race; add coherent-snapshot verification regression, Windows CI, and portability/terminology/layout corrections.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.2
Close confirmation-board residuals; add retained real-PyMaster integration benchmark and regression coverage; clarify receipt and production-threshold claims.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.2
Truth-audited confirmation closure: real PyMaster benchmark, current supersession state, corrected tolerance semantics, direct artifact links, and protected-field receipt wording; readiness holds 56.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.1
Truth-audited first-board closure with full-hash typography fix: fail-closed inputs, 23 tests, narrowed provenance claims, JORS structure; readiness holds 56.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.1
Truth-audited first-board closure: fail-closed spectrum/statistical inputs, 23 tests, narrowed content-binding guarantees, corrected physical artifacts, and JORS structure; readiness holds 56 pending confirmation and archive.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.0
Major publication-architecture correction: focused namaster-proof 0.1.0 software metapaper; mirror-discovery regression closed; readiness holds 56 pending exact review.
PAPER-1B bumped to v2B.0.0
Major publication-architecture correction: replace the rejected standalone JCAP companion with the focused namaster-proof 0.1.0 software metapaper; 19 tests and independent example; readiness holds 56 pending exact review.
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.112
Truth-audited v1B.0.111 closure: bind active BBN prose to executed PRIMAT table, distinguish mean-bandpower and realization-level NaMaster estimators, correct cosine-flat angular-prior median, and repair equation overflow; readiness holds 5
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.112
Truth-audited v1B.0.111 closure: bind active BBN prose to executed PRIMAT table, distinguish mean-bandpower and realization-level NaMaster estimators, and correct cosine-flat angular-prior median; readiness holds 56 pending confirmation.
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.111
Physical CAMB NaMaster 500-MC production and eight-configuration robustness suite completed; version-matched immutable manifest retained; readiness held pending exact re-review and human review.
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.110
Recompute the DES-Y3 S8 overlay from the frozen chains with the declared 30% burn-in; bind raw/post-burn sample counts and artifact hashes; correct the claims-table layout for current REVTeX; readiness remains 56 pending corrected NaMaster
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.260
Bind manuscript Data Availability to the exact strict-primary overlay while retaining the immutable catalog revision and honestly recording provider publication and DOI as open gates.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.259
Close residual confirmation synchronization defects in primary audit table, harmonic null moments, mask contract, and public-release disclosure.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.139-2026-07-16
Close unanimous minor residual findings on interaction wording, pooled-reference covariance, T-Web count provenance, and deterministic ordering.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.138-2026-07-16
Eliminate isolated arXiv equation overflow in focal-model specification; no scientific result changed.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.137-2026-07-16
Promote full-rank K13 focal hierarchy; add cluster robustness and bounded program-interaction sensitivity
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.258
Exact safe-primary and common-support harmonic closure; systematics diagnostic remains non-cosmological
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.136-2026-07-15
Close exact-PDF v0.1.135 confirmation findings: promote rank-defensible K=13 focal inference; repair classifier/release provenance and figure labels; Paper IV/archive/human-review gates remain.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.257
Close exact-PDF v1.0.256 confirmation findings: correct two-declination-proxy scope and remove causal TTA overclaim; standing validation/metadata/archive gates remain.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.135-2026-07-15
Exact-PDF recursive truth-audit closure: relabel focal hybrid; add deterministic reduced-rank CR1 and wild-cluster inference; correct multiplicity and target-program language.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.256
Exact-PDF truth-audit closure: synchronize primary provenance; correct LEE and diagnostic-null descriptions, historical bias-test metrics, and unsupported causal/spatial language.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.134-2026-07-15
proactive portfolio preflight removed a false frozen-artifact claim and bounded A39/A40 to the GALZONE/VoidFinder control; no scientific result changed
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.255
close exact-board release-integrity findings with row-level quarantine identity proof, portable bootstrap, and bounded model/manuscript wording
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.254
Truth-audited Catalog B scope correction, immutable source-count disclosure, and public Catalog C semantic-contract publication
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.253
Close verified HF release-contract defects with immutable dataset/model revisions; readiness remains 80 pending standing science, DOI, and human-review gates
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.252
Public release-integrity closure: correct the stale Hugging Face dataset card and publish a byte-pinned, executable one-to-one morphology join for all 3,201,160 safe-catalog spiral rows. Primary HC result unchanged; readiness 80 holds pendi
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.251
Truth-audited bounded closure of the exact v1.0.250 board: correct WLS support, confusion-transfer wording, add-one MC tails, schema binding, bibliography order, and presentation. Primary HC result unchanged; readiness 80 holds pending trai
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.250
P4 v1.0.250 AASTeX 7.0.1 presentation closure: converted the canonical manuscript to the target ApJS class with two-column line-numbered layout and numeric citations; removed the nonstandard table-of-contents and revtex-only constructs; com
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.249
Exact-v1.0.248 MAJOR/MINOR/MAJOR truth-audit closure. Restricts the FS-C synthesis to apodization robustness and multipole coherence after verifying that quartile, leg-proxy, boundary-distance, density-null, WLS/bootstrap, and direct-cross-
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.248
Exact-v1.0.247 MAJOR/MINOR/MINOR board truth-audit closure. Corrected the public primary-null bundle at immutable HF data commit db110233 / receipt e535b262; excluded historical WLS/bootstrap and +3.80 sigma density-null diagnostics from th
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.247
Public commit-pinned ApJS catalog bundle plus exact GZ1 supported-N closure; training, covariance, DOI-backed paper archive, exact review, and human review remain open.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.246
Bounded truth-audit closure of the exact v1.0.245 board: corrected all primary fixed-occupancy-null anchors and selected-versus-supported accounting; replaced the uniform-dilution shortcut with the full two-class confusion transfer; disclos
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.245
Truth-audited v1.0.244 review closure: exchangeability-safe fixed-occupancy label shuffle is primary (z=0.7053169638, p=0.2246775322); former pixel permutation retained as robustness; training and GZ1 provenance corrected; public-title clai
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.109
Truth-audited v1B.0.108 review closure: retained 100,000-draw-per-arm spectator-conditioned ALP prior-predictive artifact; corrected executed NaMaster and S8 grids, weighted posterior summaries, and unsupported full-EB forecast; exact v1B.0
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.133-2026-07-14
Retained local DESIVAST catalog-native void non-detection candidate with corrected bounded release language; immutable public archive and human review remain open.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.244
Bounded ApJS release candidate with safe schema, compact release, deterministic primary-null reproduction, and retained transfer and selection limits. No v244 re-review.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.2.0-r8
ApJS public-ID recovery release candidate r8 with bounded association tiers, clean-checkout validation, and no purity, novelty, or detection claim.
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.122
Bounded convention-and-clarity closure on the exact contraction-phase result; automated exact-PDF board ACCEPT across subscription Codex and direct Gemini/Grok, not journal acceptance.
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.108
Bounded confirmation closure: truthful synthetic native-coordinate window description, rendered N=100000 prior-predictive method, and 195-artifact provenance inventory. No v108 re-review.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.123
Compact exact-artifact CQG Note closure; subscription-backed Codex review returned ACCEPT, but human, archive, and venue gates remain open.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.240
M24-EXT DP4-22 close: edge-on Appendix-E sensitivity penalty corrected sqrt->linear ((1-d)^-1=18.8% not (1-d)^-1/2=9.0%; naive f_CW estimator retains edge-on in N_spiral -> linear dilution). Both call sites + b/a sweep + artifact JSON updat
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.127-2026-07-13
M28-INT genuinely-new: artifact-ID range descriptors [A1]--[A32] corrected to [A1]--[A34] at 3 in-PDF sites (acknowledgments + Appendix C numbering note) + caption path-enumeration updated for A33/A34; the RSD artifacts appended in v0.1.122
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.239
Reconcile current to v1.0.239 (main/Codex state). The v1.0.240 edge-on penalty fix (DP4-22) is parked on branch tick-p4-dp4-22-edgeon-2026-07-13 pending owner integration; this tick collided with a concurrent Codex driver and yielded per th
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.240
M24-EXT (2026-07-13): GENUINELY-NEW correctness item from ChatGPT-EXT M24 (edge-on sensitivity penalty). Appendix E derived the edge-on floor inflation via a Fisher-variance scaling (1-delta)^-1/2 = 8.98%, but the primary dipole uses the NA
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.159-apjs
M22-EXT: fixed a genuinely-new Data-Availability internal self-contradiction (Gaia block release + LAMOST headline-count status) named by ChatGPT #15, verified vs live .tex; wording-only, no count changed (DP3-21). streak reset 8->0.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.20
PRD-format abstract rewrite (final standing editable item; content relocated, zero claims changed)
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.158
DP3-15 held-out re-inference: quantify pod-block (~1.3% re-pullable) + demonstrate committed 5-seed ensemble reproduces native-scale MSE axis + injrec gate; no headline number changed
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.126
M2 seven->eight term-count fix (reader-visible arithmetic-label defect; no number changed)
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.157
immutable reviewable release: RELEASE_MANIFEST.json + pinned HF tag p3-v3.1.157 (573b5da7) in DAS both variants; INT-caught consistency fixes
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.157
immutable reviewable release: RELEASE_MANIFEST.json + pinned HF revision 34319c7 in DAS both variants
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.238
v1.0.238: directive-L compute closer — full 8.47M image-level end-to-end mirror-flip injection performed through production ViT (T_raw=0.2303, T_eq=0.9997); closes ChatGPT DP4-15/Gemini image-level pseudo-label-independence MAJOR
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.125
v0.1.125: M1 wave overhaul-introduced fix — abstract 'pre-declared'->'designated-primary (exploratory, not pre-registered)' (L778), resolves the Grok+ChatGPT MAJOR#1 abstract-vs-Sec.V.B contradiction the directive-M rewrite introduced; no n
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.238
Directive-L compute closer FOLDED: full image-level end-to-end mirror-flip injection performed on all 8.47M galaxies through the production ViT — T_raw=0.2303±0.0002 (stable across confidence bins + N/S strata); Z2-TTA labeling exactly pari
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.19
DP1U overhaul + H0/MPl exponent consistency fix (10^-60 -> 10^-61 at L2639, matching L3322/L3808; true value 1.2e-61) — INT-Claude MINOR closed in-round
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.124-2026-07-12
presentation completion: PRD abstract; strip guide/rebuttal residue; systematics-budget sum as multline (fix hbox); byte-preserved numbers
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.19
DP1U presentation overhaul (overflow fix pass)
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.124-2026-07-12
presentation completion: single PRD-format abstract paragraph (352->41 lines); strip reader's-guide/co-review/rebuttal residue; fix 36pt systematics-budget hbox via display eqn; content byte-preserved
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.19
DP1U presentation overhaul: abstract repetition purge + barrier-catalog consolidation to description-list with route map + appendix E/F/G supplementary reframe; all numbers byte-preserved, zero physics change
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.116
directive-M presentation restructure; zero content change; -35/16 untouched
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.124-2026-07-12
presentation completion: single PRD-format abstract paragraph (352->41 lines); strip reader's-guide/co-review-request/rebuttal-note residue; content byte-preserved
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.237
directive-M presentation overhaul: PRD single-paragraph abstract (5 paras ~430w -> 1 para ~230w, byte-preserving all numbers) + de-dup 'sigma not comparable' caveat (removed 4 per-figure parentheticals + trimmed 2 table captions to one stat
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.17
NJ4 INT-Claude MINOR closed: leg-(B) magnitude bound now explicitly covers attractive AA channel (worst |G_AA|/G_crit=2x0.156=0.31); AA/PP flagged not-the-scalar-condensate so scalar sign leg already decisive; far->plain sub-critical in abs
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.123-2026-07-12
RSD estimand relabel (unrestricted) + sign fix + quadrature 0.898
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.16
INT-Claude leg-A scalar-channel scope fix + far->comfortably sub-critical
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.115
INT-Claude genuinely-new MAJOR closed by RE-COMPUTE: the c15 channel-native joint {f_NL,b_phi,A_GR} Fisher built the GR-projection derivative dB/dA_GR = b*b*b*S_GR WITHOUT the M123=M(k1)M(k2)M(k3) transfer product the f_NL primordial leg (b
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.115
CN1: c15 GR channel-native result demoted (potential-vs-density metric mismatch -> A_GR Fisher weight vacuous; overstated-proxy claim deleted); headline proxy floor unchanged (INT-Claude CN1r catch)
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.15
NJ1: Holst NJL factor 30x->14x per committed njl_gap script (INT-Claude catch); conclusion unchanged
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.122-2026-07-12
directive-L closure DP5-12: RSD first-order Zel'dovich reconstruction bound integrated (shift 0.024pp, ~40x under 0.9pp envelope, null preserved)
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.14
Route-1 vacuum condensate excluded by regulated NJL gap-equation analysis (repulsive channel + sub-critical coupling)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.114
channel-native joint {f_NL,b_phi,A_GR} bispectrum Fisher (c15) closes DP2 proxy-floor MAJOR by adopting the c13 tree-level Gaussian MT covariance surrogate; channel-native rho(f_NL,A_GR)=-0.001, floor 2.5sigma > proxy 1.3sigma
P3 bumped to v3.1.155
FR3 INT-Claude wave-2 truth-audit closure (DP3-19): 1 genuinely-new reader-visible correctable finding -> clean-wave streak RESET 1 -> 0. (1) matter-bounce NANOGrav parameter-shift precision made CONSISTENT with the v3.1.154 SMBHB fix: the
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.155
DP3-19: matter-bounce parameter-shift +1.13σ→+1.14σ consistency with the v3.1.154 full-precision SMBHB +4.63σ fix (chain 1.13543); F_0 0.01239→0.01240 (downstream 0.01509→0.01510; σ=8.14 unchanged). 2 genuinely-new INT-Claude items verified
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.154
FR1 closure: NANOGrav SMBHB +4.61->+4.63 sigma misround fix (4 sites); DP3-18
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.13
restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.121
restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.236
restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.153
restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.113
restamp + recompile at program-exit state (no content change)
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.120-2026-07-10
W3-INT confirm wave: dedicated v0.1.118/119/120 changelog block of record for the void-stratum integration (was previously only a retro-annotation on the v0.1.116 block); comment-only, no reader-visible change [Claude W3-INT MINOR#1]
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.119
close missed de-attenuation site: void measurement now cited in §XII-B (predecessor closure completed)
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.119
close missed XII-B de-attenuation site — void measurement now cited (predecessor mid-flight closure completed)
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.12
W1-INT: propagate v1U.0.11 Check D fix (-3/8 J5.J5) to dim4_parityodd_enumeration.py + abstract eps-eps=-3!delta; Claude INT MAJOR closed (artifact/abstract sync per directive-I6)
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.235
re-mirror: heal 3-way served-PDF divergence caught by verify-only (no content change)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.112
Claude-referee presentation closures: PRD abstract, proxy-floor disclosure, certify-framing, cite fixes
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.112
Claude-referee presentation closures: PRD abstract, proxy-floor disclosure, certify-framing, cite fixes
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.118
void-stratified confusion measurement integrated (closes last OPEN-COMPUTE recipe item)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.111
H17F Grok-minor closures: DAS repo pointer, abstract rephrase, clarity items
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.117
Re-assert v0.1.117 as current (directive-G validation re-run had re-inserted a v0.1.116 row with newer createdAt, stealing the tie-break).
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.235
H17 loop iter-2: closed the one genuinely-new Claude-ACCEPT cosmetic nit - corrected imprecise 'disjoint subsamples' to 'distinct (nested) subsamples' (the confident-spiral stratified set is a high-confidence subset of, not disjoint from, t
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116
directive-G script validation re-run
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.234
H17 INT re-test closure: closed 3 genuinely-new Claude-subagent MINORs on the v1.0.233 sky/confidence-stratified confusion analysis (Appendix B). Softened Sec IV C cannot-manufacture phrasing to corroborates-but-does-not-fully-close; added
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.117-2026-07-10
H17 retest2 close: fixed two stale primary=+0.0007 labels to promoted footprint-restricted +0.0018 (n_void=57,081); sharpened 2a-1 symmetry claim to adjacent-strata-not-void-axis + accuracy-reconciliation sentence (0.912 vs 0.699); repointe
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.233
v1.0.233 (H17 science upgrade): new Appendix-B subsection Sky- and confidence-stratified human-label confusion analysis + Table tab:gz1_stratified (5 strata: overall/BASS+MzLS/DECaLS/science-cut/low-conf; N, acc, CW->CCW / CCW->CW, asymmetr
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.116-2026-07-10
H17 cross-paper integration: committed GZ1-overlap stratified human-vs-classifier CW/CCW confusion matrix (pipelines/p2_chirality/outputs/gz1_stratified_confusion.json, commit 84d53b75) integrated into the recurring 'no environment-stratifi
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.11
H17 EXT re-test closure: ChatGPT Check-D MAJOR (genuinely-new internal inconsistency) fixed. Check D (Appendix) and the O4/O5 reduction printed S_abc S^abc = 6(J5.J5) using eps_abcd eps^abce = +3! and dropping the (1/4)^2=1/16 from S=(1/4)e
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.110
H17 INT re-test: 4 editable Claude MINORs closed vs committed artifacts (abstract sign-gloss reword; continuous-marg BF 4.8->4.6 reconciled to c9k 4.615; tab:gr -35/8 refs 3.5e8/4.5e5/6.4e2->3.0e8/4.2e5/6.1e2; c9k/c9g stale metadata refresh
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.232
H17 re-test v1.0.231->v1.0.232: closed 3 INT MINORs (Claude retest) — stale z=-18 straggler in Primary-Results callout caption (816) -> z=-7.6; stale naive-WLS z=-264.5 in WLS table caption (1370) -> z=-112 (both post-Shamir-correction stra
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.152
H17 INT re-test (v3.1.151) truth-audit: 1 VERIFIED-NEW editable fix (INT-Claude MAJOR#1 headline 37.3M scan-volume bookkeeping) closed via reconciliation footnote (no new numbers); INT-OpenAI/Grok-API REJECTs reviewed stale v3.1.144 (re-fla
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.109
H17 ChatGPT EXT addendum: corrected the stale tab:gr BF-vs-SSFSR column + P(BF>3) + sigma_GR=0.05 calibration + continuous-marginalization SSFSR + tab:bayes SSFSR column, all of which were still at the superseded -35/8 center while the Tune
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.115
H17 second closure: 57,081 exact-count primary made single primary everywhere (abstract/title/intro/§XV); k=20 56,981 confined to labeled sensitivity-control rows. New consolidated Bonferroni-5 family table (all 5 rows, common sign conventi
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.114
H17 closures: primary estimand unified to footprint-restricted exact +0.0018; Table X exact-count block; GALZONE text matched to code; Data Availability Statement added.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.151
H17 closures: three-gate framing honestly downgraded (production gate + correlated proxy checks); provenance reconciliations (37.3M read/scored; 195,790 vs 195,829 DESI); per-survey cut definitions clarified.
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.108
H17 round P2 closure: corrected Cai spurious-term sign to -(99/128)Sum k^3 and the printed-polynomial->-35/8 mechanism claim (both inconsistent with committed scripts; transcribed A_T reduces to -305/64, not Cai's stated -35/8) per Grok EXT
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.231
H17: Shamir factor-of-2 fix. Shamir's 1.7%-4.0% is a full-count asymmetry (N_CW-N_CCW)/(N_CW+N_CCW) identical to A_p, so A_ref 0.034->0.017, block-bootstrap z -18.1->-7.6, tension 7-18x->3.7-8.8x. Every text site + WLS table + bootstrap fig
P3 bumped to 3.1.151
H17 ChatGPT-EXT truth-audit: 3 VERIFIED-NEW editable fixes (residual three-gate framing at contributions list relabeled to single production-gate; Planck top-1% header clarified as 0.10% of native bank; 195,790-vs-195,829 primary-coadd gap
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.10
H17 truth-audit closure: (b) relabeled the vector-axial four-fermion Holst partner as arising only under NON-MINIMAL coupling per Freidel-Minic-Takeuchi (PRD 72 104002) - minimal coupling gives only the axial-axial R1 term; fixed the abstra
P3 bumped to v3.1.150
H17 INT-Claude integrity closure (VERIFIED-NEW, not a re-flag): the two fold-based DESI gates (5-fold Jaccard 0.862, held-out tail-preservation rho=1.00) are computed from the SAME per-fold score vectors of short-trained proxy models that F
P5 bumped to v0.1.114-2026-07-10
H17 round: fixed primary-estimand inconsistency (Conclusions now lead footprint-restricted +0.0018 as primary, matching abstract/VIIIB); added exact-membership void row (57081/28339) to Table X so +0.0018 reproduces from integer counts; cla
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.113-2026-07-10
G15 closure: Bonferroni-5-first framing + de-attenuated 2.26pp physical bound + App B non-covariant-EFT hardening. Presentation-only.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.230
G15 closure: z-18 template-disfavor caveat + 47pct remainder<A50 sentence + Shamir mechanism context + Fig10 caption. Presentation-only.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.9
G15 closure: MCMC-envelope reframe + Eq.6 mass-dimension presentation + Grok/ChatGPT minors. Presentation-only, no verified number changed.
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.229
F14 closure: end-to-end transfer-calibration scope statement; asymmetric-confusion slope g_eff=s_CW+s_CCW-1=0.398 equals symmetric g=2a-1; image-level end-to-end injection honest-flagged as new simulation. No number changed.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.8
F14 closure: R4 spectator-ALP framing sharpened (ECH-specific rigid-coupling 22-36 OOM overshoot vs generic m_theta~H_0 quintessence tuning). No number changed.
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.112
F14 closure: dual-primary reconciled (footprint-restricted +0.0018 primary, unrestricted +0.0007 secondary), footprint!=selection-function distinction, 0.9pp quadrature term-sum, simultaneous Bonferroni-5 bound (|df_CW|<~1.1pp). No verified
R-round dispatched on paper-5 (houston-external)
F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
R-round dispatched on paper-4 (houston-external)
F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
R-round dispatched on paper-3 (houston-external)
F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
R-round dispatched on paper-2 (houston-external)
F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
R-round dispatched on paper-1a (houston-external)
F14-2026-07-09 · reviewers: ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.7
Process-leak scrub (no number changed, nothing fabricated). Two body-text sentences that referenced the internal review process were rewritten as standalone scientific prose: the Sec II A 2 dimension-4 operator-bookkeeping paragraph now sta
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.228
CV-round (2026-07-09) EXT closure: framing/relocation of the harmonic residual (below recovery threshold, origin unresolved — not 'non-cosmological'), hemisphere-LEE recast (rejects random-label null but attributed to systematics), GZ1 huma
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.228
CV-round (2026-07-09) EXT closure: framing/relocation of the harmonic residual (below recovery threshold, origin unresolved — not 'non-cosmological'), hemisphere-LEE recast (rejects random-label null but attributed to systematics), GZ1 huma
P3 bumped to v3.1.149
CV-round EXT closure (framing/figure only, 0 verified numbers changed): (B1) new consolidated per-survey provenance Table in §III (public-archive -> read/scored -> thresholded -> count-retained -> tier), reproduced from existing values only
P5 bumped to v0.1.111
CV-round EXT closure (2026-07-09; ChatGPT MAJOR-revisions reopened off CA ACCEPT, Grok/Gemini MINOR). Framing/relocation only; every verified number unchanged EXCEPT the stated systematic envelope, which was WIDENED (never tightened). B1: h
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.107
W12 EXT presentation closure. NO headline number changed (-35/16 UNCHANGED), nothing fabricated. Closed the presentation majors: Grok MegaMapper Fig-2 headlining (scoped as future/Stage-V, SPHEREx range headlined) + endpoint-language drift
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.107
W12 EXT presentation-closure: neutral tone on Cai et al. (arithmetic error->one identified discrepancy), stale MegaMapper 3-7sigma->1.5-3.85sigma, GR-bracket disclosure in abstract (~0.8-2.75sigma), Table V relabeled scenario/scoping budget
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.6
W12 EXT closure. Dimensional truth-audit: ChatGPT RIGHT — the bare Table-VII invariants O1/O2/O4/O6 are naive dim-2, not dim-4, so 'dimensionless c_n' was a main-text transcription slip (appendix derivation was correct). Fixed: new Eq.(dim4
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.148
CA-round ChatGPT-4-MAJOR closure: NEOWISE mixed-validation label, SecI science-target/native-threshold reader-guide, at-submission reproducibility commitment; no verified number changed
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.110
CA-round polish closure: filament program-row split, boxed real-vs-redshift-space Conclusions callout; no science number changed
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.227
CA-round polish closure: Table V reader-note, abstract not-a-loophole line, exact qc_flip filter cmd, CW/ACW->CCW; no science number changed
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.106
W11 EXT presentation-closure: calibrated -35/16 claim to exact vertex-sum+Li framing, made SPHEREx additive-quadrature budget an explicit displayed equation, labeled MegaMapper decisively uncalibrated high-z, fixed stale f_NL~-4. -35/16 unc
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.5
W11 EXT presentation-closure: formal dim-4 off-shell operator into main-text Eq.6 (new Eq.7, closed O1-O6 basis, dim-+1 = on-shell shorthand, App B.1 cross-ref) = THE ask; Grok polish list closed. No number changed.
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.106
W11 EXT presentation-closure: calibrated abstract to vertex re-summation yields -35/16 exactly + Li independent derivation decisively favors it (ChatGPT claim-strength; algebraic map already displayed); made SPHEREx additive-quadrature budg
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.5
W11 EXT presentation-closure: brought the formally dim-4 off-shell parity-odd operator into the main text at Eq.6 (new Eq.7, closed O1-O6 basis; dim-+1 = on-shell presentation shorthand, App B.1 cross-ref) = THE ask (ChatGPT B2 + Gemini Blo
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.147
W10 accept-track closure: 268,519-validated sole headline, NEOWISE geometry-QA validation-basis disclosure elevated, SDSS continuity-slice threshold clarity, DESI 2,468 science-target foregrounded, cosmology sections scoped as demonstration
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.109-2026-07-09
W10 accept-track minor closure: post-hoc caveat to abstract headline, definition-family-null framing for void-membership bound, RSD redshift-space clarifier in abstract and Conclusions, Paper IV co-review contingency sentence, sensitivity-e
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.226
W10 accept-track minor closure: ChatGPT/Grok/Gemini polish minors (incommensurable-σ table note, GZ1-null-test scope, ~47% residual future-approach, A95 conservative-grid label, injection axis convention, parity-sector context, A_p footnote
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.4
REAL-WORK closure of v1U.0.3 EXT majors: DERIVED the genuine local dim-4 parity-odd operator completion (App B, Table VII O1-O6, symbolic-verified script; single-scale NDA closure survives at dim 4 without on-shell dressing), WROTE OUT the
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.225
R9 ACCEPT-track minor closure: Grok=minor-revisions, Gemini=Accept-with-minor-revisions; both referees concrete minors closed with real edits (no number changed). Abstract z-18 now explicitly a model-dependent template-disfavor statistic (n
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.105
R9 closure: per-vertex term-by-term derivation table (App A Table VII) walking each of Cai's four cubic vertices through squeezed+equilateral limits (fNL summing exact-fraction to -35/16 / -255/128, transcribed verbatim from committed sympy
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.146
R9 EXT closure: held-out anomaly-tail-preservation OOS test (rho=1.00+/-0.05, min 0.94, gate>=0.5 PASS) directly answers the in-sample-scoring major; main-text 5,384 QSO-candidate tracer selection added (Grok minor). No count changed, nothi
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.108-2026-07-09
R9 closure: consolidated next-leading-systematics budget (each sub-dominant to 0.34-0.37pp membership term, 0.5-0.6pp envelope unchanged); DR2 pre-registration commitment; Paper-IV coordinated co-review request unmissable at flag site; T-We
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.3
P1U EXT closure wave: Gemini 2 MINORs closed (parity-odd terminology clarity at Sec IV D/Footnote 3 + companion non-load-bearing disclosure made unmissable); Grok MAJORs dispositioned (self-disclosed scope / falsified-vs-source). No number
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.2
P1U INT merge-seam closure: (SEAM1) companion-framing of now-internal appendices rewritten to an honest Result-provenance map; (SEAM2) dangling 'Table I' sample-count ref fixed — 309,189 raw accepted samples VERIFIED from committed chains (
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.2
P1U INT merge-seam closure: (SEAM1) companion-framing of now-internal appendices rewritten to an honest Result-provenance map; (SEAM2) dangling 'Table I' sample-count ref fixed — 309,189 raw accepted samples VERIFIED from committed chains (
PAPER-1A bumped to v1U.0.1
UNIFIED PAPER 1: P1B merged into P1A per unanimous reviewer recommendation (Houston-approved 2026-07-08). P1A v1A.0.115 body + proven-Fierz appendix + P1B v1B.0.104 as appendices (MCMC/DeltaN_eff methodology, NaMaster validation, ALP prior-
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.104
Deep-Grok MAJOR closure: displayed Appendix-A vertex algebra (collapsed exact vertex-sum degree-9 polynomial + epsilon-order-grouped squeezed contributions -5/2,+5/16,0 -> -35/16), transcribed verbatim from committed sympy certification scr
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.224
Deep-tier Gemini MAJOR closure: self-contained training-provenance table + probabilistic-calibration paragraph (real top-label ECE lower bound from committed GZ1 confusion matrix, ECE>=0.36 3-class / >=0.25 chirality), proven invariant to m
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.104
Deep-Grok MAJOR closure: displayed Appendix-A vertex algebra (collapsed exact vertex-sum degree-9 polynomial + epsilon-order-grouped squeezed contributions -5/2,+5/16,0 -> -35/16), transcribed verbatim from committed sympy certification scr
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.224
Deep-tier Gemini MAJOR closure: self-contained training-provenance table + probabilistic-calibration paragraph (real top-label ECE lower bound from committed GZ1 confusion matrix, ECE>=0.36 3-class / >=0.25 chirality), proven invariant to m
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.103
RSD (redshift-space) tree bispectrum Fisher (c14) applied: retires the real-space-monopole-only limitation with real computation. Kaiser Z1 + SCF99/Sefusatti Z2, growth f(z)=fsigma8/sigma8 from same CAMB Planck2018, orientation-integrated (
P3 bumped to v3.1.145
Pod-gated closure: EXACT spatial-uniformity chi^2 recomputed on the 377,482 post-excision headline set. Prior drafts reported chi^2=376,713 on the full inclusive 378,280 set (incl. now-excised Gaia-500 + eROSITA-298) and stated the exact re
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.107
v0.1.107 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.144
v3.1.144 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.104
v1B.0.104 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.115
v1A.0.115 closure-wave version sync (Convex was sorting a stale row current)
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.104
FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: off REJECT, every editable item closed.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.115
FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: all 4 Gemini MINORs closed.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.144
FULL8 closure sitePdfPath correction: title reframed to anomaly-candidate catalog (268,519 unchanged).
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.104
FULL8 closure (off REJECT): LiteBIRD 9sigma/0.7sigma pairing, DNeff EFT-estimate scope, NaMaster foreground-free caveat, ALP prior-sensitivity framing, DOI note. No number changed.
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.115
FULL8 closure: all 4 Gemini MINORs closed (R4-naturalness framing, Fierz-lemma scope, NDA limitation, Sec X quantum caveat, App B heuristic). No number changed.
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.144
FULL8 closure: title reframed to anomaly-candidate catalog of reconstruction-outlier sources (268,519 unchanged); eROSITA/Gaia exclusion made unmissable. No number changed, no disclosure weakened.
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.102
Tone-regression rewrite (Gemini MAJOR): neutralized rebuttal/defensive register in Sec IX.E (signpost paragraph recast as declarative scope summary), Sec IX.E body ('We emphasize that a detection' -> neutral), Sec template ('a referee may a
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.102
Tone-regression rewrite (Gemini MAJOR): neutralized rebuttal/defensive register in Sec IX.E (signpost paragraph recast as declarative scope summary), Sec IX.E body ('We emphasize that a detection' -> neutral), Sec template ('a referee may a
P5 bumped to v0.1.107
FULL8 EXT closure (2026-07-08): closed all Grok+Gemini MINORs + ChatGPT editable MAJORs. Abstract headline scoped to DESIVAST void/non-void contrast + post-hoc caveat + family-wise emphasis. Conclusions: post-hoc pre-registration caveat + f
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.223
FULL8 EXT round closure (Grok+Gemini MINOR REVISIONS, ChatGPT MAJOR REVISIONS). Grok: GZ1-human-only independence cross-check forward pointer added Sec II; Table I cosmological-weight footnote; Table VII synthesis sentence. Gemini: peq>0.6
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.106-2026-07-07
POSTPOLISH R-round visibility sharpening (presentation only; zero numbers changed): surfaced the deduplicated-by-construction disposition of ChatGPTs duplicate-coadd / non-disjoint-parent concern at the DESIVAST primary void/non-void count
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.222
POSTPOLISH R-round visibility sharpening (presentation only; no science number changed): added an impossible-to-miss bottom-line lead sentence stating the a-fortiori cosmological bound on the ~47% unmodelled l=1 residual (entire residual <
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.143
REALWORK re-test ITEM-2: sharpened Grok process-volume framing — first prose use of 268,519 now carries science-target benchmark 2,468 in the SAME sentence (process-volume vs like-for-like ~0.92x Liang2023); every headline-count use audited
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.101
REALWORK re-test ITEM-1: closed ChatGPT r=0.84 vs r_eff~0.99 apparent inconsistency — ONE crisp reconciliation at sec:spherex (r=0.84 flat-weight shape cosine = conservative recast factor; r_eff~0.99 survey-optimal squeezed-dominated amplit
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.100
Independent bispectrum Fisher built (c13): reproduces Heinrich sigma(f_NL^local)=0.626/0.687 (within 2-11%, PASSED); at the bounce template sigma(f_NL^bounce)=0.632/0.689 -> r_eff~0.99, unmarginalized 3.46/3.18 sigma for -35/16. Retires the
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.100
Independent bispectrum Fisher built (c13): from-scratch tree-level multi-tracer Fisher on the committed SPHEREx public-products table reproduces Heinrich sigma(f_NL^local)=0.626/0.687 (within 2-11%, validation PASSED); at the bounce templat
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.114
Fierz-by-Fierz projection lemma PROVEN + machine-verified (arxiv/scripts/fierz_lemma_check.py -> LEMMA PROVEN) and applied: closes the 'completeness asserted, not proven' MAJOR at the M_Pl-power-counting-class level the paper claims. New ap
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.142
v3.1.142 eROSITA tier cleanly excised (production rescaling code lost = irreproducible by provenance): 298 objects removed from every inclusive count (377,780->377,482 chain stated in-paper), released separately as reproducible membership a
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.105
P-round + venue-compliance: author-responsibility/not-an-author clause added; standalone-verified arXiv bundle (2026-07-07).
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.141
P-round final: standalone-verified arXiv bundle + venue-policy compliance (2026-07-07); datestamp normalized to human format for correct version sort.
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.99
P-round path fix: corrected served PDF path to /papers/ (leading slash).
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.141
P-round final: standalone-verified arXiv bundle + venue-policy compliance (2026-07-07).
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.221
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (consistency pass, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): AI-methods now names the models used (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 2026 + OpenAI GPT-5/o3 + xAI Grok-4 + Google Gemini 2.5). No science number changed. Recompile 0
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.221
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (consistency pass, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): AI-methods now names the models used (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 2026 + OpenAI GPT-5/o3 + xAI Grok-4 + Google Gemini 2.5). No science number changed. Recompile 0
P5 bumped to v0.1.105
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (Edit B, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): added explicit author-responsibility + not-an-author clause AND model naming (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 2026 + OpenAI GPT-5/o3 + xAI Grok-4 + Google Gemini 2.5) per MNRAS/
P3 bumped to v3.1.141
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (Edit A, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): added explicit author-responsibility + not-an-author clause AND model naming (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 2026 + OpenAI GPT-5/o3 + xAI Grok-4 + Google Gemini 2.5) per AAS/IO
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.99
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (Edit C, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): AI-methods now names models (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 2026 + OpenAI GPT-5/o3 + xAI Grok-4 + Google Gemini 2.5) per IOP/JCAP. No science number changed. Recompile 0 undef,
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.103
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (consistency pass, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): AI-methods disclosure now names the models used (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 family 2026, with OpenAI GPT-5/o3, xAI Grok-4, Google Gemini 2.5). No science number c
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.113
Venue-compliance disclosure edit (Edit C, VENUE_POLICY_COMPLIANCE.md): AI-methods disclosure now names the models used (Anthropic Claude Opus 4 family 2026, with OpenAI GPT-5/o3, xAI Grok-4, Google Gemini 2.5 as cross-check/internal-review)
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.104
Site-sync fix: correct sitePdfPath to the actual served v0.1.104 filename (was pointing at site/public/p5-chirality.pdf which returned SPA HTML on the home Read-PDF link).
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.112
v1A.0.112 POSTPOLISH figure-image correction: fig_theory_map.png still rendered the superseded matter-bounce f_NL=-35/8 in its prediction box while the body was uniformly -35/16 (value baked into the PNG, invisible to text grep). Regenerate
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.140
Packet-consistency sweep: sync Convex to served v3.1.140 (20-word title postpolish).
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.98
Packet-consistency sweep: sync Convex to served v1.7.98 (final post-polish state).
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.104-2026-07-07
POST-POLISH INT fix: embedded 3 D-round-regenerated 300-dpi serif figures (fig_p5_cw_by_env_bar, fig_p5_phase2_sensitivity_heatmap, fig_p5_volume_fractions_pie) that had been served stale at 150 dpi (no graphicspath). Presentation-only, zer
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.220
v1.0.220 post-polish INT catch: restored the A_p=2(f_CW-1/2) mapping clause to the abstract (prevents z~-7.6 unit misread of the Shamir comparison)
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.98
D-round final polish (presentation + disclosure only, no science number changed, -35/16 unchanged): abstract restructured to lead with the -35/16 Cai-Li resolution then forecast then load-bearing caveat (was caveat-dense); colorblind-safe p
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.219
D-round final polish (presentation + disclosure only, no science number changed): condensed title to 'A Null Chirality Dipole in 8.5 Million DESI Galaxies from Equivariant Deep Learning'; abstract rewritten reader-first (result -> method ->
P5 bumped to v0.1.103-2026-07-06
D-round final polish (presentation + disclosure ONLY, 0 numbers changed): title trimmed (dropped tidal-tensor tail; footnote condensed to sec:vweb pointer); abstract reordered to lead with the null result (void-vs-non-void dfCW consistent w
P3 bumped to v3.1.140
D-round final polish (presentation + disclosure ONLY, 0 numbers changed): title sharpened 24->20 words (kept 268,519 validated + 37.3M); abstract rewritten first-time-reader (lead with catalog + real-object demo, process-volume disclaimer s
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.102
v1B.0.102 final-polish D-round (presentation + disclosure ONLY; NO science changed; 0 undef-refs, 22pp). AI-methods disclosure upgraded (agentic-pipeline-under-author-direction + results-verified-against-committed-artifacts; public-audit-tr
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.111
v1A.0.111 final-polish D-round (presentation + disclosure ONLY; NO science changed; 0 undef-refs, 37pp). Closed Gemini EXT excessive/repetitive-disclaimers: collapsed the v110 over-applied coordinated-submission phrase 17->1 sites (zero hon
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.102
v1B.0.102 final-polish D-round (presentation + disclosure ONLY; NO science changed; 0 undef-refs, 22pp). AI-methods disclosure upgraded (agentic-pipeline-under-author-direction + results-verified-against-committed-artifacts, Cobaya configs/
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.111
v1A.0.111 final-polish D-round (presentation + disclosure ONLY; NO science changed; 0 undef-refs, 37pp). Closed Gemini EXT excessive/repetitive-disclaimers: collapsed the v110 over-applied coordinated-submission phrase 17->1 sites (zero hon
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.97
FIGURE HYGIENE: regenerated fig1_shape_function.png and fig4_decision_thresholds.png, which still rendered the stale -35/8-era labeling (last regenerated 2026-06-26) while every text/table headline already carries the corrected -35/16. fig1
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.96
DATA-UNLOCK: strengthened the named Cov_B external gate in sec:systematics with one sentence. A systematic availability search (arXiv ancillary files, Zenodo, authors' public code repositories) confirms the Heinrich et al. 2023 per-triangle
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.96
DATA-UNLOCK: strengthened the named Cov_B external gate in sec:systematics with one sentence. A systematic availability search (arXiv ancillary files, Zenodo, authors' public code repositories) confirms the Heinrich et al. 2023 per-triangle
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.218
DATA-UNLOCK: the edge-on-ISOLATED argmax tie-break coherence (Gemini App E strengthening item, previously pod/data-lab-deferred) is now COMPUTED on real data. Joining catalog_production (class_eq/RA/Dec) to the committed spiral_morphology_d
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.139
DATA-UNLOCK: closed the deferred DESI score-vs-z test with a real, honestly-mixed result from the public DESI DR1 Redrock zcatalog. Strengthening: all 195,790 DESI anomalies join on TARGETID (100%) -> 98.8% GALAXY / 1.07% (2,102) QSO (media
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.110
v1A.0.110 publication-readiness + coordinated-submission companion reframe: harmonized abstract/fbox scope de-sync (Jackiw-Pi CS + parity-odd 4-fermion now uniformly closed in-body, only Fierz lemma deferred); recast in-prep companions to c
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.95
Publication-readiness finalization: swept the last stale -35/8-era significances (five downstream spots + the bphi_sensitivity figure title/legend) to the corrected -35/16 halved values, and reconciled the Appendix-A -35/8-origin wording (S
PAPER-5 bumped to v0.1.102-2026-07-06
Paper-IV coordinated-submission reframe: recast the dominant cross-reviewer major (unvettable in-prep dependency) into a citation-timing note. Paper IV = companion catalog paper in this repo (pipelines/p2_chirality/), submitting first wave;
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.101
Publication-readiness finalization for coordinated submission: standalone-value framing (first-principles bespoke ECH-sector DeltaNeff bound surfaced in abstract/intro) + coordinated [arXiv:XXXX.XXXXX] cross-ref placeholder. Content error-c
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.217
P4 RETEST v215->v217 EXT closure (Grok+Gemini both MINOR REVISIONS, central claim robustly supported; INT ACCEPT). v216: closed Gemini's 2 remaining MAJORs — derived an explicit statistical upper limit on the cosmological content of the ~47
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.109
Route 2 (one-loop Holst/parity-odd) UPGRADED from free-normalization ansatz to ONE-LOOP-GROUNDED via Shapiro & Teixeira 2014 (arXiv:1402.4854): loop factor 1/(16pi^2), O(1) Immirzi-rational coefficient beta(gamma) [alpha_4=-6/(1+g^2), Omega
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.94
INT-v3-P2 systematic-budget MAJOR (Grok+Gemini RS27 joint-covariance) upgraded from PROXY to COMPUTED GR-projection degeneracy. dB/dA_GR = S_GR relativistic-projection squeezed kernel constructed on the paper's own 23,098-triangle grid; com
P4 bumped to v1.0.217
P4 RETEST v216 EXT closure (Grok + Gemini both MINOR REVISIONS, central claim supported). Editable minors closed as WORDING/CLARITY tightenings, nothing fabricated: (1) Grok Sec V.A/abstract Shamir 'inconsistent' restated in the abstract as
P4 bumped to v1.0.216
Close Gemini's 2 remaining MAJORs. EDIT 1 (Sec IV.D): statistical upper limit on the cosmological content of the unmodelled ~47% l=1 residual — observed canonical-mask A1_obs=0.695% (same Ap=2(f_CW-1/2) units as the real-space dipole) is BE
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.215
P4 v215 DRIVE-TO-ACCEPT: (1) Shamir unit-consistency fix - amplitude tension restated ~7-18x comparing both in A_p units (0.455% A_p vs Shamir 1.7-4.0% f_CW = 3.4-8.0% A_p); (2) ~47% l=1 residual physical-origin discussion added (diagnostic
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.214
INT_v3 closure (Grok+Gemini #1 gating): pseudo-label-independence check upgraded from underpowered N=14,964 to a PROPERLY-POWERED, FULLY MODEL-INDEPENDENT test using Galaxy Zoo 1 Table 2 HUMAN CW/ACW votes (Lintott 2011) DIRECTLY as the chi
PAPER-4 bumped to v1.0.213
R2026-07-05 Grok+Gemini minor-revision closure: prominent GZ1-only zero-pseudo-label rebuttal (z=-0.04), Primary Results callout table, git-pre-spec 0.6 cut provenance, residual explicitly reframed diagnostic-not-gating (~47% pod-deferred),
PAPER-2 bumped to 1.7.93
INT-v3-P2 ROUND_2026-07-05 two MINOR fixes (final PDF md5 after bibtex regen): (1) softened the -35/8 error attribution in App A honestly (the +(99/128)Sum k_i^3 term is ONE identified discrepancy within Cai s unstated full printed-polynomi
PAPER-2 bumped to 1.7.93
INT-v3-P2 ROUND_2026-07-05 two MINOR fixes: (1) softened the -35/8 error attribution in App A to be honest (the +(99/128)Sum k_i^3 term is ONE identified discrepancy within Cai s unstated full printed-polynomial reduction, not the sole doub
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.108
INT review (v107, ROUND_2026-07-05, Claude Code full-source leg — verdict MINOR) flagged three REAL internal inconsistencies from the fast v106/v107 edits; reconciled with NO physics/number changes. MINOR-1: abstract Scope de-synced from bo
PAPER-1B bumped to v1B.0.100
Close INT MINOR-1/2/3: reduced-M_Pl DeltaNeff box (1.7e-43 BBN, 1.1e-56 recomb), ALP thermal-factorization parametric-estimate qualifier, Table IV strict-sliver cited to c10a_spectator_slice.json with coarser Omega_a cuts labeled illustrati
PAPER-3 bumped to v3.1.138
MINOR-1/MINOR-2 polish: clarified 67.3%-at-z>2 is of the anomaly-selected QSOs; added note that external ~2.15x enrichment-baseline block is intentionally not cited in-text (prior-dependent, non-load-bearing). No numbers changed.
PAPER-3 bumped to 3.1.137
INT real-science closure of detection-significance MAJOR: added VERIFIED SDSS QSO high-z enrichment demonstration to sec:sdss (76.3% QSO, 198 at z>6, Mann-Whitney p=1.05e-103; Spearman rho=+0.036).
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.92
INT-v3 verified-real-science: closed the non-local-tails reviewer MAJOR ('the r=0.84 local-template recast does not model the NON-LOCAL bounce-shape tails; equilateral/orthogonal deviations could carry missed signal') with a standard-basis
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.107
Closed ChatGPT 'non-exhaustive operator basis' MAJOR: upgraded four-route enumeration from illustrative/non-exhaustive to exhaustive within minimal ECH by symmetry + NDA monotonicity. (F1) algebraic non-propagating torsion + (F2) totally-an
PAPER-2 bumped to v1.7.91
TWO verified-real-science INT-v3 strengthenings. EDIT 1: cubic bounce transmission now DERIVED to a bounded systematic (closes assumption-(d) MAJOR). The Cai-Wilson-Ewing LQC quasi-dust bounce is single-clock (effective LQC adds no new scal
PAPER-1A bumped to v1A.0.106
CRUX REFRAME: rho_Lambda dark-energy mapping recast from on-shell scaling ansatz to a controlled single-scale NDA dimensional no-go. Parity-odd operator off-shell dim +1; NDA forces Wilson coeff Lambda^{4-d}=Lambda^3; minimal ECH single-sca
Showing up to 300 events. Older history in git log (github.com/Hubify-Projects/bigbounce) and SSOT/queue.md.