EXT2 — in-thread delta round · manifest
Round: EXT2 (2026-06-10, same 18 chat threads as EXT1; revised PDFs + delta-prompts) Versions reviewed: v1A.0.58 / v1B.0.56 / v1.7.50 / v3.1.89 / v1.0.173 / v0.1.62
Verdict movement (EXT1 → EXT2)
| Paper | ChatGPT Pro Ext | Grok Heavy | Gemini Thinking |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1A | REJECT → MAJOR ("moved substantially toward publishability") | MAJOR → ACCEPT | MAJOR → MINOR |
| P1B | MAJOR → MAJOR | MINOR → ACCEPT | MINOR → MAJOR |
| P2 | MAJOR → MAJOR | MINOR → MINOR | MINOR → MINOR |
| P3 | MAJOR → MAJOR | MAJOR → MINOR | MAJOR → MINOR |
| P4 | MAJOR → MAJOR | MINOR → ACCEPT | MINOR → ACCEPT |
| P5 | MAJOR → MAJOR | MINOR → ACCEPT | MAJOR → MAJOR |
10 of 18 verdicts improved; 7 held; 1 regressed (Gemini P1B MINOR→MAJOR — to be truth-audited). Reports: EXT2_<paper>_<Provider>.md (this directory). Next: EXT2 truth-audit + gap metric vs the 60-finding EXT1 baseline.