Three blind non-Anthropic native-PDF legs reviewed the same 14-page artifact at source commit 7cf60218 and SHA-256 024931a4…39dc concurrently. The independent Codex subscription leg is a declared NOT_RUN gap because its weekly allowance was exhausted; no substitute verdict was created. Truth audit confirms a real chance-association/random-shift control, an accepted-versus-warned comparison enabled by the existing 2,267-row auxiliary product, and an explicit original-member sensitivity. Final archive/DOI packaging remains a workflow gate. Grok's 20,299,153 mismatch is an OCR false positive—the exact source/PDF use 20,299,155 throughout—and 7.33% correctly rounds 181/2468. No readiness uplift.

P3 v3.2.0-r5 exact-PDF ApJS review

The 14-page manuscript at source commit 7cf60218b521a8154f9ad6ed3b58c0bbc420ab59 and PDF SHA-256 024931a40e88124f75f2f6872549936e909db0a3b504dbd2e4e68e91878a39dc received OpenAI MAJOR REVISIONS, Gemini MINOR REVISIONS, and Grok MINOR REVISIONS in a blind, concurrent, non-Anthropic native-PDF panel. The separately declared independent Codex subscription leg was not run because its weekly allowance was exhausted; no substitute verdict was created.

Truth-audit result: the catalog remains in revision. The real scientific closures are a deterministic chance-association/random-shift control, a compact accepted-versus-warning-bearing population comparison using the already-built 2,267-row auxiliary product, and an explicit original-member-separation sensitivity. Final DOI/archive packaging remains a workflow gate.

Two flags were false positives: all exact source/PDF occurrences use the 20,299,155-row denominator, and 181/2468 = 7.333873...%, so 7.33% is correct rounding. No readiness score was raised from verdict words alone.

Full raw reports and the source-cited audit are preserved in project-context/peer-reviews/INT_v3/ROUND_2026-07-14-P3-v3.2.0-r5-EXACTPDF-024931a4-APJS-NONANTHROPIC-CONFIRM/.